Wednesday 18th July 2018

Home » Frontpage » Currently Reading:

Does Scripture Allow For Pre-adamic Animal Suffering?

June 20, 2018 Frontpage No Comments

Fr. Brian W. Harrison, O.S.

 

I missed seeing Philip Trower’s reply (“Creation and Evolution Revisited”, The Wanderer, October 26, 2017, p. 8A) to my critique of his original article on evolution until months after it was published, so I apologize to The Wanderer and to you, dear reader, for the tardiness of this further response. It will help to begin by refreshing our memories.

The debate between Mr. Trower and myself is over whether, in order to explain theologically the millions of years of innocent animal pain, terror, and bloodshed which according to the ‘long-ages’ evolutionary worldview occurred prior to the Fall of man, we may postulate not only that God gave the angels “power to influence the evolutionary or transformative creative process” but also that he did not withhold or withdraw this power from the fallen angels (cf. P. Trower, “Creation, The CCC, Evolution And Angels”, The Wanderer, July 13, 2017, p. 8B). In short, Mr. Trower, impelled by his assumption that the aforesaid worldview is true and that the traditional Judeo-Christian alternative – young-earth, six-day creationism – is false, hypothesizes that we should blame Satan and his cruel minions for the (supposed) existence of carnivorous and predatory beasts prior to Adam’s Fall, and thus, for the untold pain they both inflicted and suffered.

In my response, published in the September 7, 2017 issue of The Wanderer (p. 7B), I criticized this novel theological hypothesis on three main grounds:  First, I argued (supplying links to relevant websites) that we no longer needto resort to an unheard-of hypothesis like Mr. Trower’s, because third-millennium empirical science is discovering scores of indications that radically challenge the premise on which it’s based, namely, that the earth and its lower animals were around for countless eons prior to the appearance of man. As a result of these discoveries, the traditional literal and historical reading of Genesis, rather than the various evolution-driven, but exegetically artificial, non-historical readings (figurative, symbolic, mythical, or whatever) now looks increasingly tenable and is making a come-back.

Secondly, the idea that any angels at all (never mind wicked angels) actively influenced the process of creationcan claim no support whatever from Scripture or Tradition (and obviously none from empirical science either). Thirdly, I argued that the whole idea of long ages of carnivorous animal suffering is in itselfcontrary to the clear theological message of Genesis 1 – acknowledged even by those who deny its historicity – that prior to the Fall of Adam and Eve, the whole earthly creation was “very good” (Gn. 1: 31). Indeed, that idea specifically contradicts the closely related text telling us that all animals at that time were vegetarian (v. 30).

In what follows I will explain why I don’t think Mr. Trower, in his October rejoinder, succeeds in refuting the above criticisms of his position. But first, I should point out that we share more common ground than he thinks we do. He says my position “seems to be that favored by the Kolbe . . . Center [for the Study of Creation]”.Well, I resigned from the Kolbe advisory board years ago because of their claim that Catholics are required by the infallible dogmatic teaching of Lateran Council IV (and even Vatican Council I), to reject the ‘long ages’ version of earth’s history, along with evolution in any shape or form. Like most theologians, I think this reads too much into the teaching of these councils. I favor young-earth, six-24-hour-day creationism, not because I think the Magisterium requires this traditional view, but because the Magisterium’s ‘big tent’ allows it, and I think there is compelling exegetical evidence that it is what the inspired writers intended to teach.

Mr. Trower first objects to the title of my 9/7/17 article (“Did Demons ‘Help’ God Create the World?”), insisting that in his view the demons would not have “helped” but rather, “interfered with”, the process of creation. Well, sure. In the body of my article I recognized that. But I think the word “Help” in my title – placed in quotation marks to show it wasn’t meant literally as a constructive,desirabletype of participation – was nevertheless legitimate. After all, Mr. Trower’s theory does in fact depict demonic activity as a contributing factor, albeit a harmful one, in an overarching creative process that he sees as dialectical – conflictive – in character.

Therefore, the comparison he now draws between this supposed demonic intervention in the creative process and mere mindless, destructive vandalism – lopping the leg off a beautiful table or covering it with scratches – is inappropriate and misleading. Mr. Trower uses this comparison to fend off my charge that his theory (according to which evil spirits are to blame for the savage, pain-inflicting character of many beasts) runs afoul of the Council of Braga’s condemnation of the idea that some creatures were made by demons. But it’s obvious that a carnivorous animal is very far from being just a mutilated or wounded herbivore! Its distinctive features display intelligent design. Mr. Trower has offered no answer to my objection that his theory in effect ascribes to created spirits “the delegated but awesomely godlike power of determining the detailed anatomy of birds, fish and animals (their types of teeth, claws, paws, beaks, digestive systems, etc.)”.

And what of the atheist’s objection that I cited? (“A God who would freely create beasts programmed to terrorize, tear apart and devour other creatures would be a cruel sadist! In fact, he’d be the Devil!”). Mr.Trower sees this as nothing more than a restatement of the well-known ‘problem of evil’: “To this objection, as everyone knows”, he writes, “there are no cut and dried answers. Why does God allow innocent suffering? We are dealing with a profound mystery.” We are indeed – as I too acknowledged in the first column of my initial critique of Mr. Trower’s thesis. But I think he is missing my point there, which is that on the basis of six-24-hour-day creationism one can at least retort to the atheist that in the beginning God did not in fact create any beasts as carnivorous. Rather, in the original earthly paradise all creatures (including, therefore, dinosaurs, lions, tigers, eagles and hawks) were peaceable vegetarians, as Gn. 1:30 clearly states.Some of them became savage carnivores only as part of the deathly curse with which God afflicted the whole earth after Adam, its divinely-appointed governor, opted to follow Satan’s lie rather than God’s command (cf. Gn. 3:17-18).

But if Mr. Trower’s hypothesis is right, there never was any earthly paradise! Rather, creation is an unfinished evolutionary project in which God allowed demons to cause untold innocent animal suffering for millions of years before Adam sinned. (Incidentally, since Mr. Trower clearly does not read Gn. 1:30 as literal history, one wonders how he does interpret that verse, and what linguistic or textual evidence he – or anyone – can adduce to show that the inspired author never intended it to be read as literal history.)

I suppose that by emphasizing to the atheist cited above that it was in fact the Devil, and not God, whom we should blame for animal suffering before Adam, Mr. Trower’s response might be roughly as effective as my own approach in terms of theodicy (defending God’s goodness). But its effectiveness in that limited area will come at an unacceptably heavy price in others. First, the more responsibility he ascribes to evil spirits for the existence of carnivorous beasts, the more difficult it will be for him to escape censure by the Council of Braga (see above). And secondly, this same emphasis on supposed pre-Adamic diabolical influence over the creative process will only accentuate the principal point on which I think Mr. Trower’s theory, and indeed, any form of theistic evolution, runs up against biblical truth, namely, the manifest incompatibility between these supposed millions of years of innocent suffering and the central teaching of Genesis that the original creation, prior to Adam’s sin, was “very good” (Gn. 1:31).

The rest of Mr. Trower’s rejoinder is basically an argument from authority, focusing on what he sees as the tension between my six-day creationist position and the Catechism of the Catholic Church.He even hints that I’m adopting a Protestant-style ‘private interpretation’ of Genesisbased on Sola Scriptura premises. Not at all! My position is shared with the great majority of the Catholic Church’s Fathers and Doctors, andhas not been censured (though it’s certainly not favored) by recent,evolution-influenced, magisterial teaching.

I find unpersuasive Mr. Trower’s arguments from silence, e.g. the CCC’s lack of any reference in no. 400 to animal death, and from its use of quotation marks. Such features no doubt indicate the Catechism’s unwillingness to endorse literal six-day creationism; but they don’t amount to a doctrinal censure of that position. They can be read quite naturally as implying the Church’s reluctance to impose any particular chronology of earth history – either the prevailing ‘old earth’ evolutionary worldview or the contrary ‘young earth’ view – as a requirement of Catholic orthodoxy.

For instance, placing “six days” in quotation marks (no. 339) could simply imply that the Church wants to continue her long-standing permission for Catholics to debate freely whether yom (“day”) in Genesis 1 means a natural day or “a certain period of time” (cf. 1909 Response of the Pontifical Biblical Commission, Dz 2128, DS 3519).   Mr. Trower also appeals to the CCC’s statement that “Scripture presents the work of the Creator symbolicallyas a succession of six days of divine ‘work’ concluded by the ‘rest’ of the seventh day” (no. 337, emphasis added). But in this sentence it’s not the term six days that the Catechism places in quotation marks, but the words “work” and “rest”. That seems to imply it’sthese words that we’re to understand “symbolically”, in accordance with the Church’s recognition from patristic times onward that the biblical creation accounts contain certain anthropomorphisms that don’t apply literally to God.

Finally, I see a certain irony in Mr. Trower’s concluding cautionary reference to the Vatican’spre-18th-century insistenceon aquestionable scientific theory – geocentrism – as a requirementof Catholic orthodoxy. Not only do I make noclaim that my ownbelief in a literal six-day creation is required by the Church’s Magisterium; but I would say it’s precisely Mr. Trower who should be heeding his own warning!For he too appears to be insistingon aquestionable scientific theory – in this case, belief that the earth is billions of years old – as a requirement of Catholic orthodoxy. And the fact that the authority he appeals to is the current universal Catechismmakes his warning doubly ironic. For its predecessor, the Church’s catechetical ‘gold standard’ for four centuries prior to Vatican II, taught that same geocentric thesisthat Mr. Trower holds up to me as an obvious error! (In Part I, Ch. II, Q. 18 of the Catechism of the Council of Trent we read that God, “by his word, commanded the earth to stand in the midst of the world, ‘founded upon its own basis’”. And in Ch. IV. Q. 4,wefind thisbiological error: “[T]he body of Christ was formed from the most pure blood of the Virgin Mother.”)

Even papally approved catechisms can be unreliableif they try to wed the Church’s doctrine too uncriticallyto thedominantscientifictheoriesof their own day.

Share Button

2017 The Wanderer Printing Co.

Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter Elects New Superior General

LINCOLN, Neb. — The general chapter of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, a society of apostolic life that celebrates the extraordinary form of the Roman rite, Monday elected Father Andrzej Komorowski as its next superior general. The July 9…Continue Reading

Catholic-heavy Supreme Court moves right as the church moves left

(RNS) — With his nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh to replace the retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy, President Trump has succeeded in doing for the judicial branch what he has often failed or neglected to do in his administration: acting efficiently…Continue Reading

Election of the Superior General . . . Society of Saint Pius X

Election of the Superior General On July 11, 2018, Father Davide Pagliarani was elected Superior General, for a mandate of 12 years, by the 4th General Chapter of the Society of Saint Pius X. The new Superior General is 47…Continue Reading

Paradoxes and indicators of Capella’s and McCarrick’s cases

These days we will find out whether Monsignor Carlo Alberto Capella, the former advisor to the Washington nunciature that the Vatican sentenced to five years’ imprisonment for possession and distribution of “large quantities” of child pornography, will present an appeal…Continue Reading

Diocese led by pro-gay bishop says it’s ‘up to each parish’ whether to promote homosexuality

LEXINGTON, Kentucky, July 3, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – A Catholic church in the heart of Appalachia has attracted media attention for the Gay Pride Month banner stretched across its front lawn. The local ordinary, Bishop John Stowe, has a record of collaborating with a…Continue Reading

Al Gore: Pope Francis a ‘moral force’ for solving climate crisis

(Vatican.news) Nobel Peace Prize Winner and former U.S. Vice President, Al Gore, is one of the world’s most vocal defenders of the environment. His 2007 documentary film, “An Inconvenient Truth”, won an Oscar and his Climate Reality Project recently hosted…Continue Reading

Catholic bishops heading to border to tackle family separation issues

HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) — A delegation of Catholic bishops from across the country are heading to the border on Monday. Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, will lead the delegation in its visit to the…Continue Reading

Catholic Church teaching on homosexuality ‘evil’, McAleese says

The Catholic Church’s teaching on homosexuality is “evil”, former president Mary McAleese has said. Speaking ahead of her inaugural participation in the Dublin Pride event on Saturday, where she will march with her son Justin and his husband, the former…Continue Reading

Senate Will Vote Before Elections on Replacing Pro-Abortion Justice Anthony Kennedy

The United States Senate will vote before the elections this November on a replacement for pro-abortion Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell made that announcement today shortly after the surprising but welcome announcement that the longtime abortion…Continue Reading

Cardinal Burke, Bishop Schneider respond to Pope Francis’ inflight intercommunion comments

ROME, June 27, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — The reception of Holy Communion in the Catholic Church — even in exceptional cases — by a Protestant or other non-Catholic constitutes a “lie” that betrays the Apostolic tradition and the Church’s constant practice…Continue Reading

German Bishops Publish Intercommunion Handout with a Rhetorical Trick

Today, the German bishops have published their very controversial pastoral handout which allows Protestant spouses of Catholics, in certain cases, to receive Holy Communion. Since Pope Francis, on 21 June, objected to a national bishops’ conference publishing such an official text, the…Continue Reading

Vikings host ‘LGBTQ summit’ to promote ‘inclusion’ in sports

EAGAN, Minnesota, June 21, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – The Minnesota Vikings are hosting a conference and fundraiser today for “LGBTQ inclusion in sports,” the first of its kind in the National Football League (NFL). The event will include speeches, interviews, and…Continue Reading

Untitled 5 Untitled 2

Attention Readers:

  Welcome to our website. Readers who are familiar with The Wanderer know we have been providing Catholic news and orthodox commentary for 150 years in our weekly print edition.


  Our daily version offers only some of what we publish weekly in print. To take advantage of everything The Wanderer publishes, we encourage you to su
bscribe to our flagship weekly print edition, which is mailed every Friday or, if you want to view it in its entirety online, you can subscribe to the E-edition, which is a replica of the print edition.
 
  Our daily edition includes: a selection of material from recent issues of our print edition, news stories updated daily from renowned news sources, access to archives from The Wanderer from the past 10 years, available at a minimum charge (this will be expanded as time goes on). Also: regularly updated features where we go back in time and highlight various columns and news items covered in The Wanderer over the past 150 years. And: a comments section in which your remarks are encouraged, both good and bad, including suggestions.
 
  We encourage you to become a daily visitor to our site. If you appreciate our site, tell your friends. As Catholics we must band together to rediscover our faith and share it with the world if we are to effectively counter a society whose moral culture seems to have no boundaries and a government whose rapidly extending reach threatens to extinguish the rights of people of faith to practice their religion (witness the HHS mandate). Now more than ever, vehicles like The Wanderer are needed for clarification and guidance on the issues of the day.

Catholic, conservative, orthodox, and loyal to the Magisterium have been this journal’s hallmarks for five generations. God willing, our message will continue well into this century and beyond.

Joseph Matt
President, The Wanderer Printing Co.

Untitled 1

Interview With Cardinal Burke . . . Discriminating Mercy: Defending Christ And His Church With True Love

Cburke3

  By DON FIER (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke, Patron of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta and Founder of the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, Wis., graciously took time out of his busy schedule to grant The Wanderer a wide-ranging interview during a recent visit to the Shrine. Included among the topics…Continue Reading

Developing Lives Of Peace After The Heart Of Mary

By RAYMOND LEO CARDINAL BURKE (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke delivered the address below at the 32nd Annual Church Teaches Forum, “The Message of Fatima: Peace for the World,” Galt House, Louisville, Ky., July 22, 2017. The address is reprinted here with the kind permission of Cardinal Burke. All rights reserved. This is part one of the…Continue Reading

Catechism

Today . . .

British pro-lifers say abortion clinic ‘buffer zones’ harm women and children

London, England, Jul 12, 2018 / 12:49 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- After a decision from the United Kingdom’s High Court, two women are attempting to overturn a ban on prayer and public discussion of abortion near a British abortion clinic. On July 2, the High Court of England and Wales upheld a “buffer zone” imposed by Ealing Council, west London, around a Marie Stopes abortion clinic. The zone prevents any pro-life gathering or speech, inc

Calligraphers face jail time for not promoting same-sex ‘weddings’

PHOENIX, Arizona, July 13, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — Two Arizona calligraphy artists faced with fines and jail time for declining to take part in promoting gay “weddings” are asking the state’s Supreme Court to hear their challenge to the city of Phoenix’s law that compels them create artwork that violates their religious beliefs. Joanna Duka and Breanna Koski, owners of Brush & Nib Studio, face up to six months in jail, $2,500 in fines, and three

Bishop Paprocki disagrees with US bishops’ support for unions that fund abortion, LGBT

SPRINGFIELD, Illinois, July 11, 2018, (LifeSiteNews) – Hailed by free speech and religious liberty advocates alike, the United States Supreme Court recently ruled that public sector employees can no longer be required to pay mandatory fees to support unions which promote causes and political activities – including abortion – to which they are opposed. The ruling has also exposed a significant rift among the nation’s Catholic bishops. Despite public sector unions’ unabashe

Trump nominates Brett Kavanaugh to Supreme Court

WASHINGTON, D.C., July 9, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – Brett Kavanaugh is Donald Trump’s choice to succeed the pro-abortion, pro-gay Justice Anthony Kennedy on the U.S. Supreme Court, the president announced Monday night. Trump praised Kavanaugh’s committment to “equal justice under the law” and called him a “brilliant jurist with a clear and effective writing style.” He is “universally regarded as…one of the finest legal minds of our time.” Kavanaugh formerly clerked for Kennedy. “Justice Kennedy devoted his career to…Continue Reading

Prof fired by Catholic university for defending marriage has huge court win

MILWAUKEE, Wisconsin, July 6, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – The professor forced out by a Jesuit-run Catholic university for blogging about an undergrad student being assailed by his teacher for his having voiced defense of marriage has won in court. In a landmark decision Friday the Wisconsin Supreme Court said Marquette University violated John McAdams’ right to free speech when it suspended him for writing the blog post, and it ordered the University to restore McAdams immediately with his full rank,…Continue Reading

Advertisement(2)

Neither Left Nor Right, But Catholic … Old And New Tyrannies Borne Of Lust

By STEPHEN M. KRASON (Editor’s Note: Stephen M. Krason’s “Neither Left nor Right, but Catholic” column appears monthly [sometimes bimonthly]. He is professor of political science and legal studies and associate director of the Veritas Center for Ethics in Public Life at Franciscan University of Steubenville. He is also co-founder and president of the Society…Continue Reading

A Book Review… What Man Does Not Reverence, He Will Profane

By MITCHELL KALPAKGIAN Society and Sanity, by Frank Sheed (Ignatius Press: San Francisco, 2013), 261 pp. $17.95. Available from www.ignatius.com or at 1-800-651-1531. This new edition of Sheed’s 1953 classic work of apologetics brings to mind the famous myth of Procrustes’ bed. The wicked king captures his victims then tortures them if their legs do…Continue Reading

How Vice Can Absorb Virtue

By DONALD DeMARCO Just as the Devil is at war with God, so too, vices are at war with virtue. The Devil wants people to believe that God does not exist. He also wants people to believe that neither does virtue exist. He would like to demolish virtue. One way of achieving this is to…Continue Reading

Henan, China… New Limits Imposed On The Religious Freedom Of Catholics

BEIJING (AsiaNews) — The Chinese government is approving increasingly restrictive measures against Catholics in the central province of Henan. As Eglises d’Asie reports, five new rules have been imposed which include the requirement of religious working in the province to collect data and information on their faithful. A priest from the Diocese of Zhengzhou reports…Continue Reading

A Book Review… Solzhenitsyn Remembered

By JUDE DOUGHERTY Congdon, Lee. Solzhenitsyn: The Historical-Spiritual Destinies of Russia and the West. DeKalb, Ill.: NIV Press, 2017; 163 pp. This book is descriptive of the prophetic voice of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (1918-2008), who was convinced that the West has set out on a road similar to that which “led Russia into the abyss.” Solzhenitsyn…Continue Reading

Advertisement

Our Catholic Faith (Section B of print edition)

Sheep Without A Shepherd

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Sixteenth Sunday In Ordinary Time (YR B) Readings: Jer. 23:1-6 Eph. 2:13-18 Mark 6:30-34 In the first reading today, God speaks a word of woe through the Prophet Jeremiah to the shepherds who mislead the Lord’s flock entrusted to their care. God says that these shepherds scattered the flock and drove them away and did not…Continue Reading

A Leaven In The World . . . In Death The Church Gives Everything

By FR. KEVIN M. CUSICK Funerals, as many priests have learned, can often be pastorally challenging and problematic episodes. Grieving family members who are not dealing with death on a regular basis by practicing their faith are suddenly confronted with its reality upon the passing of a parent or other family member. Parents who have to bury a child sometimes…Continue Reading

Martin Luther… The Man And The Myth

By RAYMOND DE SOUZA, KM Part 2 (Editor’s Note: As this October marks the 500th anniversary of Martin Luther’s nailing his 95 theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Raymond de Souza is taking a break from his usual apologetics to correct the popular image of Luther.) + + + In the last article, I quoted from…Continue Reading

The Anatomy Of A Moral Act

By DON FIER Last week, as we considered the role that human freedom plays in the economy of salvation, it was immediately acknowledged that “man’s freedom is limited and fallible” (Catechism of the Catholic Church [CCC], n. 1739). Free will, so wondrously bestowed upon man as an essential element of his great dignity of being created “in the image and…Continue Reading

Catholic Replies

Q. What can one say to a teenage daughter or granddaughter who wears skimpy bathing suits? I know that is the “style” these days, but it seems wrong for many reasons. — M.M., Virginia. A. When our five daughters were teens, my wife and I ruled out the wearing of skimpy bathing suits, as well as skin-tight jeans or shorts…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… St. Veronica Giuliani

By CAROLE BRESLIN In July, the month of the Precious Blood, the Catholic Church remembers saints by the name of Veronica. On July 12, the memorial of Veronica (meaning “true image”), the saint from the first century who presented her veil to wipe the face of Jesus, is celebrated. Three days before that, on July 9, St. Veronica Giuliani is…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… Blessed Pier Giorgio Frassati

By CAROLE BRESLIN Our Lord had a special love for the poor when He walked this earth. At one time He rebuked one of the apostles, saying, “The poor you will always have with you” (Matt. 26:11). Rather than avoiding the destitute or shun the homeless, Christians are called to love them as we love ourselves. At the beginning of…Continue Reading