Sunday 30th April 2017

Home » Frontpage » Currently Reading:

When Less Can Mean More . . . Further Reflections On The Faith And Historical Scholarship

January 3, 2017 Frontpage No Comments

By PHILIP TROWER

I

The present article is a sequel to the one published a few weeks ago entitled “By Word of Mouth or Pen and Paper” (see The Wanderer, November 17, 2016, p. 8B). While celebrating the achievements of Western historical scholarship, it at the same time pointed out what I believe to be two specific occupational hazards. One could compare them to the danger of cutting one’s finger when using a sharp knife or chopping off one’s foot if not careful when using an axe.
The first of these occupational hazards has been the tendency to play down oral tradition or the possibility of its accuracy over any extended period of time. The second has been the lack of attention given to the fact that with traditions passed on from the very old to the very young, a period of something like 250 years can be covered by a mere three people. I was chiefly concerned with biblical scholarship and the effect of these tendencies on Christian belief.
Here I am concerned with an occupational hazard of a different kind and its possible influence on our understanding of history in general and Church history in particular. This is the tendency for more important facts, whether moral or metaphysical or simply as causes of a general kind, to get hidden by the immense mass of now well-established historical detail.
It is not so much a question of “not being able to see the wood for the trees” or of “not being able to see the trees for the wood”; or rather which are the rarer and therefore more precious trees. When it is a matter of trying to determine the cause or meaning of historical events obviously not all historical facts are of the same value and a mass of detail can make the more important less visible.
I was set on this line of thinking a number of years ago when I came across the French phrase — “haute vulgarization” which roughly means “popularization for the well-educated.” A good example would be the late Sir Kenneth Clarke’s television series Civilization, ultimately published in book form.
The well-educated are intellectually capable of understanding a scholarly account of some aspect of history. But by the end of the day most professional people don’t have the time or energy for it. They would like to know about the subject but in a less detailed form. However, as far as most of the scholarly world is concerned, any degree of simplification will be seen as of necessity involving some decree of falsification.
Here they would seem to have Alexander Pope on their side. “A little learning is a dangerous thing.” But experience has suggested to me that with regard to history, simplification at times leads to deeper understanding. Who, for instance, could say that Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice does not give us insights into her period and human nature in general, which the most detailed historical and psychological studies would be incapable of conveying?
I am not trying to discredit historical scholarship in any way. As I have already said, it is among the greatest achievements of Western civilization. It has succeeded in mapping with amazing accuracy the majority of things the human race has done and said and thought since humans first appeared on our planet, and has also gone a long way to explaining why they have done and said and thought what they did.
It is also important that students of the subject should be taught to respect historical accuracy, and avoid making statements without adequate supporting evidence.
But while exploring the details of past history can be fascinating and rewarding in itself, like visiting remote foreign countries full of strange animals and birds or marvelous museums packed with beautiful or ingenious artifacts, it does not of itself always result in greater intelligibility. This is why I am maintaining that there times when less can lead to more; to greater understanding or intelligibility.
May I illustrate my point by taking an example from the history of Christian-Muslim relations? Down the ages both sides have written whole libraries of books on the subject, sometimes to discredit the other side, at other times to reach greater understanding.
St. Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Contra Gentiles would be an example of the latter. At the same time, there have been Western scholars who have enjoyed using the temporary cultural superiority of the Muslim world in the 11th and 12th centuries to discredit Christianity.
But in all this I have never come across any writer highlighting the radical difference between the first three centuries of the two religions and the way they spread, which possibly says more about them than any other fact or set of facts.
Christianity spread because the Christians were prepared to be thrown to the lions for their beliefs and the pagans, in the words of Tertullian, were impressed by the way they loved one another. Islam spread mainly by military conquest. Within a hundred years it had mastered the whole of North Africa, a large part of Spain and penetrated into France.
I am not suggesting that Christian rulers have not subsequently used force in illegitimate ways, but these have ultimately been recognized as illegitimate. Meanwhile, the striking contrast between the ways in which the two religions expanded in the first three centuries of their lives, tends to get hidden from view by the mass of less important historical detail.

II

At this point I should like to mention a different point about historical scholarship which every Christian scholar or student ought to keep in mind.
Historical scholarship, as an internationally recognized intellectual discipline, is concerned with the natural order. The supernatural order and its influence on the natural lie outside its scope. At the deepest level, therefore, the causes of historical events remain unknown to it. It does not recognize or deal with their existence.
For Christians and other believers it will, of course, be different.
In the first place, in every period there will be the influence of countless holy people, the majority probably unknown, drawing down blessings on their fellow men and women in a way that can only be accounted for in a few cases, while at the same time there will be those who are facilitating the activity of evil spirits.
Then there is the action of grace on the individual human soul and its acceptance or rejection. I try to demonstrate this in my historical novel A Danger to the State, which, among other things, is about the attempts of Europe’s 18th-century Catholic kings to force the Pope of the time to suppress the Jesuits.
In the center of the book I have a scene where the King of Spain Charles III is sitting in the garden of his palace at Aranjuez trying to make up his mind whether or not to join them. His thoughts go back and forth drawn first by a voice that says Yes, then by the voice that says No. Eventually he comes down on the side of the Yes voice with crucial consequences for hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of souls.
How much in human history must have depended on similar battles of conscience! We can guess that they may have taken place and the motives which are likely to have swayed the individual one way or another. Henry VIII’s break with the Pope would be another example. But they are not open to historical analysis and determination in the strict sense. We cannot know how much or if any grace was given.

III

Coming back to my thesis that less detail can result in deeper understanding, or too much detail renders essentials harder to see, what should make it of special interest to Catholics is its having in the last 50 years been taken up by the Magisterium.
I am referring to a distinction which it first began to make at the time of Vatican II and which Popes Benedict and Francis have recently brought to the fore again. I mean the distinction between the kerygma and the didache, or between the initial “proclamation” of the Good News and its subsequent development over the centuries in the form of Catholic doctrine and theology.
It is not a question of either/or, but of ensuring that exclusive or too great emphasis on one or the other does not distort the overall truth of the faith or render essential elements less visible.
Luther’s sola Scriptura can be seen as an example of overemphasizing the kerygma. It ignores the fact that by itself Holy Scripture, or the kerygma, is not self-explanatory. That is why the didache is necessary. The didache is the sum total of the Church’s attempts to answer all the questions put to it over the centuries by inquirers about the meaning of this or that statement or passage in the kerygma.
For instance, when our Lord tells the apostles to baptize people in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, does that mean there are three Gods? Since the answer is No, we can see the question as the starting point of all the volumes that have been written over the centuries about the doctrine of the Trinity.
A story in the Fioretti of St. Francis of Assisi illustrates the point I am trying to make. (I quote from memory.) An old woman once asked St. Francis why theology was necessary. Surely she could save her soul without having to learn a whole lot of dogma and theology? True, replied St Francis. You don’t need to know it all, but the Church has to.
If Luther’s sola Scriptura represents the kerygma overshadowing the didache, we find the alternative situation, the didache overshadowing the kerygma, in the situation at the end of the Middle Ages which gave rise to the movement known as the devotio moderna of which the author of The Imitation of Christ, Thomas à Kempis, is the best-known member.
He bewails a situation where, as he sees it, scholarly in-fighting over theological niceties was obscuring the most rudimentary Gospel principles; particularly those about loving our neighbor or having the spirit of little children.
This is why today we find our Pope Emeritus Benedict, before his retirement, concerned that the need to defend fundamental moral principles should not leave the impression that that is what Christianity is mainly or only about: a collection of negatives.
He did not say the principles in question do not have to be defended. As we all know, he is himself a famous scholar and theologian. However their defense must be balanced by an equal insistence on kerygmatic fundamentals; for example, the truly Pauline principle that Christianity is first and foremost an “encounter” or living with and in Christ.
St. Paul was equally anxious not to leave the impression on his hearers that the faith was some kind of ideology or system of ideas rather than a supernatural mystery, and this was in spite of the fact that some of the Church’s most intricate doctrines have their origin in his letters.
With much the same object in mind, Pope Francis has been directing our attention to the role of the poor and disadvantaged. There can be no true encounter with Christ or following of our Lord which neglects or overlooks them.
As I said, it is not a matter of either/or. As so often with the faith, it is a matter of keeping complementary opposites in balance while seeing that first things really do come first and that less is not obscured by more.

Share Button

2017 The Wanderer Printing Co.

Raymond Desouza . . . Shield of Faith PART 5

Chris Manion . . . European Union's Demographic Whimper; Vatican Hosts The Enemy; Can Rogue Federal Judiciary Be Controlled?

 

Pope Francis: Don’t be ‘more Papist than the Pope’

ROME, Italy, April 28, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) –  Pope Francis spoke critically again of the faithful who have a strong embrace of Catholic doctrine, resorting to pejorative terms he has often used such as hypocritical and phariseeism. “You cannot be more…Continue Reading

Trump appoints pro-life leader to top Health and Human Services spot

WASHINGTON, D.C., April 28, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – President Trump appointed well-known pro-life activist Dr. Charmaine Yoest to be Assistant Secretary of Public Affairs at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The man Yoest is replacing is now a…Continue Reading

Advisor close to Pope Francis accuses dubia cardinals of ‘a new pharisaism’

April 24, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – The leader of the Pope’s Council of Nine cardinals said the dubia cardinals haven’t read Amoris Laetitia and wondered why they haven’t “said anything about those who manufacture weapons.” Cardinal Óscar Rodríguez Maradiaga made these remarks during a radio interview…Continue Reading

NYC Catholics accuse Cardinal Dolan for ‘playing both sides’ as shuttered churches open doors to illegal immigrants

LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) – The banner was a line from Matthew 25, in which God will speak to those who cared for their neighbor. The scripture states: “When the Son of man comes in his glory, escorted by…Continue Reading

Iowa lawmakers pass bill defunding Planned Parenthood

DES MOINES, Iowa, April 21, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – The Iowa House of Representatives and the state Senate voted this week to deny $400,000 to 12 Planned Parenthood clinics in the state and redirect patients to other federally-qualified community health facilities.…Continue Reading

Black Abortionist Calls Pro-Life People Racist Because We’re Upset Black Babies Are Aborted

Abortionist Willie Parker seems to thrive on making nonsensical and outrageous statements that get him attention. Often, the southern abortion practitioner likes to say he is a Christian who performs abortions because of his faith. But this week, he turned…Continue Reading

Confirmed: Pope will canonize Fatima visionaries in May

VATICAN CITY, April 20, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – Pope Francis will canonize Blessed Jacinta Marto and Blessed Francisco Marto, the two siblings who witnessed the Virgin Mary’s appearances at Fatima, during his upcoming visit to the site of the apparitions on…Continue Reading

The Catholic Church still cares about Latin

Vatican City, Apr 19, 2017 / 06:01 am (CNA/EWTN News).- Existing in some form since several hundred years before Christ, the Latin language seems like an unlikely subject to still be generating brand new research, especially among young scholars. Nevertheless,…Continue Reading

Trump signs law allowing states to defund Planned Parenthood

WASHINGTON, D.C., April 13, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – President Trump signed a law today overturning a last-minute Obama-era regulation forcing states to fund Planned Parenthood, America’s largest abortion business. The regulation, which pro-life groups call former President Obama’s “parting gift” to…Continue Reading

French presidential hopeful slams Pope Francis for welcoming migrants

ROME (RNS) France’s National Front presidential candidate, Marine Le Pen, slammed Pope Francis for welcoming migrants and attacked the Catholic Church for meddling in French politics. With just over a week to critical national elections, the far-right candidate said Friday…Continue Reading

GOP Leaders to Drop Funding for Border Wall from Budget – Paul Ryan Says Maybe Next Year

GOP leaders are ready to burn President Trump and remove funding for the Trump border wall in order to woo Democrats in the Senate. Republicans hold a majority in both the US House of Representatives and US Senate. And –ALREADY–…Continue Reading

Planned Parenthood Will Give Pro-Abortion Hillary Clinton Its “Champion of the Century” Award

Hillary Clinton will receive a consolation prize from one of her top supporters, Planned Parenthood, in May. The abortion chain announced Thursday that it chose the failed presidential candidate to receive its “Champion of the Century” award for “her 40…Continue Reading

Untitled 5 Untitled 2

Attention Readers:

  Welcome to our website. Readers who are familiar with The Wanderer know we have been providing Catholic news and orthodox commentary for 150 years in our weekly print edition.


  Our daily version offers only some of what we publish weekly in print. To take advantage of everything The Wanderer publishes, we encourage you to su
bscribe to our flagship weekly print edition, which is mailed every Friday or, if you want to view it in its entirety online, you can subscribe to the E-edition, which is a replica of the print edition.
 
  Our daily edition includes: a selection of material from recent issues of our print edition, news stories updated daily from renowned news sources, access to archives from The Wanderer from the past 10 years, available at a minimum charge (this will be expanded as time goes on). Also: regularly updated features where we go back in time and highlight various columns and news items covered in The Wanderer over the past 150 years. And: a comments section in which your remarks are encouraged, both good and bad, including suggestions.
 
  We encourage you to become a daily visitor to our site. If you appreciate our site, tell your friends. As Catholics we must band together to rediscover our faith and share it with the world if we are to effectively counter a society whose moral culture seems to have no boundaries and a government whose rapidly extending reach threatens to extinguish the rights of people of faith to practice their religion (witness the HHS mandate). Now more than ever, vehicles like The Wanderer are needed for clarification and guidance on the issues of the day.

Catholic, conservative, orthodox, and loyal to the Magisterium have been this journal’s hallmarks for five generations. God willing, our message will continue well into this century and beyond.

Joseph Matt
President, The Wanderer Printing Co.

Untitled 1

Enter Comments Below

This Weeks Comments And Letters . . .

Culture Of Life 101 . . . “An Introduction To The Problem Of Euthanasia”

By BRIAN CLOWES Part 2 (Editor’s Note: Brian Clowes has been director of research and training at Human Life International since 1995. For an electronic copy of chapter 23 of The Facts of Life, a 150-page treatise on all of the aspects of euthanasia, e-mail him at bclowes@hli.org.) + + + We have covered the definitions of the varieties of…Continue Reading

Today . . .

In Trump’s first 100 days, Catholics find a mixed bag

Washington D.C., Apr 29, 2017 / 05:27 am (CNA/EWTN News).- Catholic leaders have found cause for both praise and concern after the first 100 days of Donald Trump’s presidency. “Catholics have reason for optimism. But like the first 100 days, the road ahead remains difficult,” Brian Burch, president of CatholicVote.org, said on the organization’s scorecard for the first 100 days of the Trump presidency. Abortion Pro-life leaders have found a lot to like from the…Continue Reading

Enough with the liturgical translations!

The immortal Yogi Berra said it best: “It’s déjà vu all over again.” That was my first reaction to the news that a new Vatican commission had been established some time back to consider—again—the question of liturgical translations. Really, you can’t help wondering if another round in the debate about the words of the Mass is exactly what disputatious Catholics—already arguing amo

Trump admin keeps Obama rule requiring Little Sisters of the Poor to pay for contraception … for now

April 25, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – The Trump administration’s Department of Justice (DOJ) caused surprise today by signaling that it intends to continue the Obama administration’s court battle with the Little Sisters of the Poor and other religious groups over the HHS contraception mandate, at least for the time being. While Trump had promised on the campaign trail to drop the provision, the DOJ has now asked the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals for 60 more…Continue Reading

FSSP Superior Distinguishes Fraternity from SSPX, Eschews “Traditionalist” Label

The usually cautious and reserved Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP) has now given its current opinion concerning the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) and on its possible formal re-integration into the structures of the Catholic Church. Father Bernhard Gerstle – the head of the German district of the FSSP – just gave a 24 April interview to the German Bishops’ official website Katholisch.de in which he explains many of the positions and opinions…Continue Reading

Cardinal Sarah: Church is facing ‘grave risk’ of schism over morality

NEW YORK, April 24, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) — Cardinal Robert Sarah warned that the Church’s unity is being threatened by influential leaders within the Church who “insist” that national churches have the “capacity to decide for themselves” on doctrinal and moral matters. “Without a common faith, the Church is threatened by confusion and then, progressively, she can slide into dispersion and

Pope Names New Head Of Chicago Eparchy

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Pope Francis has named Bishop Venedykt (Valery) Aleksiychuk, MSU, as bishop of the Eparchy of St. Nicholas in Chicago for Ukrainians, in Illinois. Prior to the appointment, Bishop Aleksiychuk was an auxiliary bishop of the Archeparchy of Lviv, Ukraine. The appointment was publicized in Washington, D.C., on April 20 by Archbishop Christophe…Continue Reading

Restoring The Sacred The Hands Of A Queen

By JAMES MONTI When in His infinite wisdom and love God fashioned man in His image and likeness, He imparted to the human body a remarkable and matching pair of members specifically crafted to imitate the Creator in His work of creation — the hands. And when in the fullness of time Our Lord refashioned…Continue Reading

At The Supreme Court… How The Media Reported On Trinity Lutheran

By JAMES ARNOLD (Editor’s Note: This commentary originally appeared on the ADF [Alliance Defending Freedom] Blog on April 26, 2017. See www.adflegal.org. The article is reprinted here with permission; all rights reserved. (James Arnold is the legal content manager for ADF. He wrote this post about Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Mo., applying for a…Continue Reading

Helen Hull Hitchcock… A Woman For Faith And Family

By DONALD DeMARCO Helen Hull Hitchcock passed away after a brief illness on October 20, 2014 at age 75. Accolades poured in from around the globe in honor of this extraordinary woman. Mary Shivanandan, a retired faculty member at the Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, and a longtime friend…Continue Reading

Fr. Jacques Hamel’s Cause Is Opened

VATICAN CITY (ZENIT) — The archbishop of Rouen, France, the Most Rev. Dominique Lebrun, confirmed the official opening of the Diocesan Cause of Beatification of Fr. Jacques Hamel, murdered by extremists while celebrating Mass in the church of St. Etienne du Rouvray, in Normandy. The archbishop made the announcement during the Chrism Mass over which…Continue Reading

Advertisement

Our Catholic Faith (Section B of print edition)

Our Savior And Redeemer . . . Prophet And Priest

By RAYMOND DE SOUZA, KM Part 5 So, Christ is our King. Being the eternal Son of God, He is King by natural right. As our Redeemer, He is King by acquired right, for He purchased us with His own Blood: “You were bought with a price,” “ransomed . . . with the precious blood of Christ” (1 Cor. 6:20;…Continue Reading

The Fruits Of Holy Communion

By DON FIER “The love of Jesus Christ reaches its highest perfection and produces the richest harvest of graces,” proclaims St. Peter Julian Eymard, “in the ineffable union He contacts with the soul in Holy Communion.” So inestimable is the value of Holy Communion worthily received, the great saint of eucharistic piety goes on to affirm, that “we profit more…Continue Reading

Catholic Replies

Q. I am a high school student who has been hearing from a teacher about how women like the late Betty Friedan did so much to free women from being “stay-at-home mothers” so they could fulfill themselves in the workplace. How true is this? — Z.M., Massachusetts. A. Not true at all. In his excellent new book Out of the…Continue Reading

Entering The Lord’s Sheepfold

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Fourth Sunday Of Easter (YR A) Readings: Acts 2:14a, 36-41 1 Peter 2:20b-25 John 10:1-10 In the Gospel reading today, we hear Jesus explaining to His disciples about the sheep gate and that anyone who enters through this gate is with the shepherd while anyone who enters into the sheepfold through another means is a thief…Continue Reading

“O Crux, Ave Spes Unica”… The Cross, The Only Hope Of The World

By FR. RANIERO CANTALAMESSA, OFM Cap. (Editor’s Note: Here is the Good Friday 2017 homily delivered in St. Peter’s Basilica by Capuchin Fr. Raniero Cantalamessa, preacher of the Pontifical Household. ZENIT News Agency made this text available; all rights reserved.) + + + We have listened to the story of the Passion of Christ. Apparently nothing more than the account…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… St. Peter Chanel

By CAROLE BRESLIN There are a number of small islands in the southwest Pacific Ocean, many of them predominantly Catholic. About 2,000 miles east of Australia is a tiny island nation for which one man paid the ultimate price for its conversion from paganism to Catholicism. St. Peter Chanel left his home in France to fulfill a lifelong desire to…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… St. Conrad Of Parzham

By CAROLE BRESLIN St. Francis Mary of Camporosso, St. Veronica Giuliani, St. Joseph of Leonessa, St. Leopold of Mandic, and St. Seraphin of Montegranaro are just a few of the 115 Capuchin men and women who have been declared saints or blesseds by the Catholic Church. There are so many that Pope St. John Paul II remarked, “They say you…Continue Reading