Tuesday 27th June 2017

Home » Frontpage » Currently Reading:

When Less Can Mean More . . . Further Reflections On The Faith And Historical Scholarship

January 3, 2017 Frontpage No Comments

By PHILIP TROWER

I

The present article is a sequel to the one published a few weeks ago entitled “By Word of Mouth or Pen and Paper” (see The Wanderer, November 17, 2016, p. 8B). While celebrating the achievements of Western historical scholarship, it at the same time pointed out what I believe to be two specific occupational hazards. One could compare them to the danger of cutting one’s finger when using a sharp knife or chopping off one’s foot if not careful when using an axe.
The first of these occupational hazards has been the tendency to play down oral tradition or the possibility of its accuracy over any extended period of time. The second has been the lack of attention given to the fact that with traditions passed on from the very old to the very young, a period of something like 250 years can be covered by a mere three people. I was chiefly concerned with biblical scholarship and the effect of these tendencies on Christian belief.
Here I am concerned with an occupational hazard of a different kind and its possible influence on our understanding of history in general and Church history in particular. This is the tendency for more important facts, whether moral or metaphysical or simply as causes of a general kind, to get hidden by the immense mass of now well-established historical detail.
It is not so much a question of “not being able to see the wood for the trees” or of “not being able to see the trees for the wood”; or rather which are the rarer and therefore more precious trees. When it is a matter of trying to determine the cause or meaning of historical events obviously not all historical facts are of the same value and a mass of detail can make the more important less visible.
I was set on this line of thinking a number of years ago when I came across the French phrase — “haute vulgarization” which roughly means “popularization for the well-educated.” A good example would be the late Sir Kenneth Clarke’s television series Civilization, ultimately published in book form.
The well-educated are intellectually capable of understanding a scholarly account of some aspect of history. But by the end of the day most professional people don’t have the time or energy for it. They would like to know about the subject but in a less detailed form. However, as far as most of the scholarly world is concerned, any degree of simplification will be seen as of necessity involving some decree of falsification.
Here they would seem to have Alexander Pope on their side. “A little learning is a dangerous thing.” But experience has suggested to me that with regard to history, simplification at times leads to deeper understanding. Who, for instance, could say that Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice does not give us insights into her period and human nature in general, which the most detailed historical and psychological studies would be incapable of conveying?
I am not trying to discredit historical scholarship in any way. As I have already said, it is among the greatest achievements of Western civilization. It has succeeded in mapping with amazing accuracy the majority of things the human race has done and said and thought since humans first appeared on our planet, and has also gone a long way to explaining why they have done and said and thought what they did.
It is also important that students of the subject should be taught to respect historical accuracy, and avoid making statements without adequate supporting evidence.
But while exploring the details of past history can be fascinating and rewarding in itself, like visiting remote foreign countries full of strange animals and birds or marvelous museums packed with beautiful or ingenious artifacts, it does not of itself always result in greater intelligibility. This is why I am maintaining that there times when less can lead to more; to greater understanding or intelligibility.
May I illustrate my point by taking an example from the history of Christian-Muslim relations? Down the ages both sides have written whole libraries of books on the subject, sometimes to discredit the other side, at other times to reach greater understanding.
St. Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Contra Gentiles would be an example of the latter. At the same time, there have been Western scholars who have enjoyed using the temporary cultural superiority of the Muslim world in the 11th and 12th centuries to discredit Christianity.
But in all this I have never come across any writer highlighting the radical difference between the first three centuries of the two religions and the way they spread, which possibly says more about them than any other fact or set of facts.
Christianity spread because the Christians were prepared to be thrown to the lions for their beliefs and the pagans, in the words of Tertullian, were impressed by the way they loved one another. Islam spread mainly by military conquest. Within a hundred years it had mastered the whole of North Africa, a large part of Spain and penetrated into France.
I am not suggesting that Christian rulers have not subsequently used force in illegitimate ways, but these have ultimately been recognized as illegitimate. Meanwhile, the striking contrast between the ways in which the two religions expanded in the first three centuries of their lives, tends to get hidden from view by the mass of less important historical detail.

II

At this point I should like to mention a different point about historical scholarship which every Christian scholar or student ought to keep in mind.
Historical scholarship, as an internationally recognized intellectual discipline, is concerned with the natural order. The supernatural order and its influence on the natural lie outside its scope. At the deepest level, therefore, the causes of historical events remain unknown to it. It does not recognize or deal with their existence.
For Christians and other believers it will, of course, be different.
In the first place, in every period there will be the influence of countless holy people, the majority probably unknown, drawing down blessings on their fellow men and women in a way that can only be accounted for in a few cases, while at the same time there will be those who are facilitating the activity of evil spirits.
Then there is the action of grace on the individual human soul and its acceptance or rejection. I try to demonstrate this in my historical novel A Danger to the State, which, among other things, is about the attempts of Europe’s 18th-century Catholic kings to force the Pope of the time to suppress the Jesuits.
In the center of the book I have a scene where the King of Spain Charles III is sitting in the garden of his palace at Aranjuez trying to make up his mind whether or not to join them. His thoughts go back and forth drawn first by a voice that says Yes, then by the voice that says No. Eventually he comes down on the side of the Yes voice with crucial consequences for hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of souls.
How much in human history must have depended on similar battles of conscience! We can guess that they may have taken place and the motives which are likely to have swayed the individual one way or another. Henry VIII’s break with the Pope would be another example. But they are not open to historical analysis and determination in the strict sense. We cannot know how much or if any grace was given.

III

Coming back to my thesis that less detail can result in deeper understanding, or too much detail renders essentials harder to see, what should make it of special interest to Catholics is its having in the last 50 years been taken up by the Magisterium.
I am referring to a distinction which it first began to make at the time of Vatican II and which Popes Benedict and Francis have recently brought to the fore again. I mean the distinction between the kerygma and the didache, or between the initial “proclamation” of the Good News and its subsequent development over the centuries in the form of Catholic doctrine and theology.
It is not a question of either/or, but of ensuring that exclusive or too great emphasis on one or the other does not distort the overall truth of the faith or render essential elements less visible.
Luther’s sola Scriptura can be seen as an example of overemphasizing the kerygma. It ignores the fact that by itself Holy Scripture, or the kerygma, is not self-explanatory. That is why the didache is necessary. The didache is the sum total of the Church’s attempts to answer all the questions put to it over the centuries by inquirers about the meaning of this or that statement or passage in the kerygma.
For instance, when our Lord tells the apostles to baptize people in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, does that mean there are three Gods? Since the answer is No, we can see the question as the starting point of all the volumes that have been written over the centuries about the doctrine of the Trinity.
A story in the Fioretti of St. Francis of Assisi illustrates the point I am trying to make. (I quote from memory.) An old woman once asked St. Francis why theology was necessary. Surely she could save her soul without having to learn a whole lot of dogma and theology? True, replied St Francis. You don’t need to know it all, but the Church has to.
If Luther’s sola Scriptura represents the kerygma overshadowing the didache, we find the alternative situation, the didache overshadowing the kerygma, in the situation at the end of the Middle Ages which gave rise to the movement known as the devotio moderna of which the author of The Imitation of Christ, Thomas à Kempis, is the best-known member.
He bewails a situation where, as he sees it, scholarly in-fighting over theological niceties was obscuring the most rudimentary Gospel principles; particularly those about loving our neighbor or having the spirit of little children.
This is why today we find our Pope Emeritus Benedict, before his retirement, concerned that the need to defend fundamental moral principles should not leave the impression that that is what Christianity is mainly or only about: a collection of negatives.
He did not say the principles in question do not have to be defended. As we all know, he is himself a famous scholar and theologian. However their defense must be balanced by an equal insistence on kerygmatic fundamentals; for example, the truly Pauline principle that Christianity is first and foremost an “encounter” or living with and in Christ.
St. Paul was equally anxious not to leave the impression on his hearers that the faith was some kind of ideology or system of ideas rather than a supernatural mystery, and this was in spite of the fact that some of the Church’s most intricate doctrines have their origin in his letters.
With much the same object in mind, Pope Francis has been directing our attention to the role of the poor and disadvantaged. There can be no true encounter with Christ or following of our Lord which neglects or overlooks them.
As I said, it is not a matter of either/or. As so often with the faith, it is a matter of keeping complementary opposites in balance while seeing that first things really do come first and that less is not obscured by more.

Share Button

2017 The Wanderer Printing Co.

Hey Democrats: You Might Win More Elections If You’d Stop Killing Your Voters in the Womb

Democrats keep puzzling about why they are losing so many elections, but they do not seem to want to hear the answer that so many people are giving: abortion. Pro-life advocates — Republican, Democrat, independent and otherwise – have been…Continue Reading

Only Pope Francis can end the ‘apostasy’ his words have caused: Italian monsignor

ROME, Italy, June 21, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) — Pope Francis could stem the “confusion and apostasy” now rampant in the Church among priests and bishops by “correcting” his own “ambiguous and erroneous words and acts,” said an Italian monsignor and former…Continue Reading

New Pontifical Academy of Life Appointee Supports Euthanasia by Starvation

An ethics study group for the Italian Jesuit magazine Aggiornamenti Sociali, headed by Fr. Maurizio Chiodi, a newly appointed member of the Pontifical Academy for Life and a theologian of the Northern Italian Theological Faculty of Milan, has joined Italian…Continue Reading

Planned Parenthood wants to have a center in Reading High School; you can help stop it

ACTION: Planned Parenthood does not belong in our schools. Contact the Reading School Board at this link. Planned Parenthood is anything but helpful for teenagers, with all the ways the abortion giant has corrupted and confused them through explicit sexual advice,…Continue Reading

Fireworks at U.S. Bishops’ meeting as Francis-appointed Cardinals oppose permanent religious liberty committee

INDIANAPOLIS, Indiana, June 15, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) voted 132 to 53 today to approve the establishment of a permanent Standing Committee for Religious Liberty. Five bishops abstained from voting. The USCCB formed the Ad Hoc…Continue Reading

What can priests practically do to combat the porn epidemic?

Washington D.C., Jun 14, 2017 / 02:59 am (CNA/EWTN News).- Online pornography is one of the fastest growing addictions in the United States, on par with cocaine and gambling. Once confined to the pages of a smuggled Playboy magazine, pornography…Continue Reading

Catholic community offers prayer, supplies for London fire victims

London, England, Jun 14, 2017 / 01:20 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- The Catholic bishops of Westminster offered their prayers and local parishes opened their doors to offer aid and supplies to those affected by a massive fire at an apartment complex…Continue Reading

Ohio tries again to ban abortions after heartbeat begins

COLUMBUS, Ohio, June 9, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – On Tuesday, two Ohio representatives reintroduced legislation protecting babies with detectable heartbeats from abortion. Last year, Republican Gov. John Kasich vetoed the measure when it came to his desk. The human heart begins…Continue Reading

Abortion clinic loses fight to silence LifeSite, but plans emergency appeal

TORONTO, June 9, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) — LifeSiteNews won a victory in court today by successfully opposing a publication ban on the identities of abortionists targeting a pro-life activist. But the legal battle continues as the Crown in Ontario has signalled…Continue Reading

Incredible Story . . . Winner of ‘Romania’s Got Talent’ is a 14-year-old girl without arms and femurs

June 6, 2017 (Family News) — When she first showed up in front of the cameras at the live show, with her serene sweet face, she looked as a much smaller child. She is a short person because her legs…Continue Reading

Bring Back Christendom

By now you may have come across the controversy spun up over the weekend when Rep. Clay Higgins, the new congressman from Louisiana’s 3rd District, sent an outraged reaction to the London Bridge jihadist attacks over Facebook. The bulk of…Continue Reading

The Organization Every Parent Needs to Know About

Did you know there’s an organization of pediatricians and other child health professionals whose policies likely support your values as Catholic parents and grandparents? The American College of Pediatricians (not to be confused with the American Academy of Pediatrics) actually…Continue Reading

Untitled 5 Untitled 2

Attention Readers:

  Welcome to our website. Readers who are familiar with The Wanderer know we have been providing Catholic news and orthodox commentary for 150 years in our weekly print edition.


  Our daily version offers only some of what we publish weekly in print. To take advantage of everything The Wanderer publishes, we encourage you to su
bscribe to our flagship weekly print edition, which is mailed every Friday or, if you want to view it in its entirety online, you can subscribe to the E-edition, which is a replica of the print edition.
 
  Our daily edition includes: a selection of material from recent issues of our print edition, news stories updated daily from renowned news sources, access to archives from The Wanderer from the past 10 years, available at a minimum charge (this will be expanded as time goes on). Also: regularly updated features where we go back in time and highlight various columns and news items covered in The Wanderer over the past 150 years. And: a comments section in which your remarks are encouraged, both good and bad, including suggestions.
 
  We encourage you to become a daily visitor to our site. If you appreciate our site, tell your friends. As Catholics we must band together to rediscover our faith and share it with the world if we are to effectively counter a society whose moral culture seems to have no boundaries and a government whose rapidly extending reach threatens to extinguish the rights of people of faith to practice their religion (witness the HHS mandate). Now more than ever, vehicles like The Wanderer are needed for clarification and guidance on the issues of the day.

Catholic, conservative, orthodox, and loyal to the Magisterium have been this journal’s hallmarks for five generations. God willing, our message will continue well into this century and beyond.

Joseph Matt
President, The Wanderer Printing Co.

Untitled 1

Enter Comments Below

This Weeks Comments And Letters . . .

Culture Of Life 101 . . . “An Introduction To The Problem Of Euthanasia”

By BRIAN CLOWES Part 2 (Editor’s Note: Brian Clowes has been director of research and training at Human Life International since 1995. For an electronic copy of chapter 23 of The Facts of Life, a 150-page treatise on all of the aspects of euthanasia, e-mail him at bclowes@hli.org.) + + + We have covered the definitions of the varieties of…Continue Reading

Today . . .

New documentary challenges the secrecy and denial surrounding abortion

“HUSH”, a film about abortion and women’s health, is a professional, persuasive piece of investigative journalism, fronted by Punam Kumar Gill, who manages to combine a dogged determination to break the silence surrounding abortion with a sensitivity borne out of her own personal experience of loss. Abortion advocates claim to be very keen on talking about abortion. They want women to shout out their abortions, to express pride and joy in a procedure they increasingly…Continue Reading

James Martin Blasts Bishop Thomas Paprocki

On June 12, 2017, Bishop Thomas John Paprocki of the Diocese of Springfield, Illinois, issued a Decree “Regarding Same-Sex ‘Marriage’ and Related Pastoral Issues.” The Decree reaffirmed Catholic teaching that a marital union is only possible “between one man and one woman.” The Decree included the following directives: No member of the clergy or representative of the Diocese should assist or participate in a same-sex marriage; No Church property should be used to host same-sex…Continue Reading

Why Cardinal Sarah terrifies his critics

A growing crowd wants Cardinal Robert Sarah’s head on a platter. Open a liberal Catholic periodical and you are likely to find a call for the dismissal of the Guinean cardinal who heads the Vatican’s Congregation for Divine Worship: “It’s past time for [Pope Francis] to replace Cardinal Sarah” (Maureen Fiedler, National Catholic Reporter); “New wine might be needed at the Congregation for Divine Worship” (Christopher Lamb, the Tablet); “Curia officials who refuse to get with…Continue Reading

Illinois Catholic bishop decrees no Holy Communion, funerals for same-sex couples

The bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Springfield, Ill., is calling on priests there to deny Holy Communion and even funeral rites to people in same-sex unions unless they show “some signs of repentance” for their relationships before death. The decree by Bishop Thomas Paprocki also said that people “living publicly” in same-sex marriages may not receive the sacrament of confirmation or be admitted to the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults, a process by w

Trump’s Nationalism Is Consistent With Catholic Social Doctrine

Leading American bishops have complained about the “harshness” of Trump’s campaign rhetoric and called for an end to deportation of aliens until the “broken” system can be fixed. Yet, despite this opposition from the Church’s hierarchy, Trump won 52% of the Catholic vote (to Hillary’s 45%), a historic margin for a Republican. How to explain this contradiction? Real simple. The laity get it better than the bishops. Trump’s nationalism is fully consistent with Catholic social…Continue Reading

Advertisement(2)

Restoring The Sacred… St. Thomas More And The Defense Of Truth

By JAMES MONTI As Catholics in America participate in the annual Fortnight for Freedom to pray for the protection of religious liberty, the example of St. Thomas More will again be invoked as in years past, with the liturgical commemoration of his martyrdom on June 22 coming only a day after the beginning of the…Continue Reading

St. Teresa Of Calcutta… Hope For A Beleaguered World

By DONALD DeMARCO “I feel the greatest destroyer of peace today is abortion, because it is a direct war, a direct killing, direct murder by the mother herself. And we read in the Scripture, for God says very clearly: Even if a mother could forget her child, I will not forget you. I have curved…Continue Reading

Our Lady Of Fatima: The May Apparition

By FR. SEAN CONNOLLY (Editor’s Note: This is the fourth in a series of articles on the one hundredth anniversary of Our Lady’s apparitions at Fatima. Fr. Connolly is a priest of the Archdiocese of New York.) + + + 1917 was a tumultuous year that would forever change the face of the world. The…Continue Reading

Atheist Christian Haters Win In Court

NEW YORK — Catholic League President Bill Donohue commented June 20 on a First Amendment case that dealt a blow to religious liberty. The full text follows: + + + For 75 years, Bayview Park, in a Pensacola, Fla., neighborhood, has been home to a large cross. The 1941 wooden cross, erected by a New…Continue Reading

A Long History Of Leftist Hatred

By PATRICK J. BUCHANAN James T. Hodgkinson of Belleville, Ill., who aspired to end his life as a mass murderer of Republican congressmen, was a Donald Trump hater and a Bernie Sanders backer. Like many before him, Hodgkinson was a malevolent man of the hating and hard left. His planned atrocity failed because two Capitol…Continue Reading

Advertisement

Our Catholic Faith (Section B of print edition)

A Leaven In The World… The Tridentine Mass Grows In Appeal

By FR. KEVIN M. CUSICK A recent appeal from a high-ranking enlisted member of the military for acceptance of exclusively Traditional priests, such as from the Fraternity of St. Peter, to serve as military chaplains was met with rejection. The subsequent headlines characterized the exchange as “Better No Chaplains Than Traditional Ones.” This reaction unfairly analyzes the practical effect of…Continue Reading

Our Savior And Redeemer… The Ascension And Pentecost

By RAYMOND DE SOUZA, KM Those people who believe in the Lutheran myth of “sola Scriptura” have a big problem to solve. They cannot explain the fact that Jesus spent forty days with His apostles, teaching them, reminding them of what He had taught them before, and preparing them for their mission, but there is absolutely nothing written in the…Continue Reading

Acts Of The Penitent — Contrition

By DON FIER As we briefly surveyed the history of the sacrament of Penance last week, we saw that significant changes in its outward form took place over the course of the centuries. In her first years, the Church experienced remarkable growth despite facing great persecution — it was a time of many martyrs. “The early Christians,” explains Dr. Alan…Continue Reading

Catholic Replies

Q. I have heard it said that homosexual behavior is one of the sins that cry out to Heaven for vengeance. Is that true and, if so, what are the others? — T.S., Arizona. A. In Holy Scripture there are four sins in this category, so called because in each case the victims of these sins cried out to the…Continue Reading

Whoever Receives You Receives Me

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Thirteenth Sunday In Ordinary Time (YR A) Readings: 2 Kings 4:8-11, 14-16a Romans 6:3-4, 8-12 Matt. 10:37-42 In the readings today we hear about our own dignity as Christian persons and also about the way we, as Christian people, are to treat others. We look first at the point of our own dignity. In the second…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… Blessed Peter To Rot

By CAROLE BRESLIN Papua New Guinea is an island nation about 175 miles north of Queensland, Australia. The capital, Rabaul, is on the eastern tip of a smaller New Guinea island that sits just east of the main island. It is an island with a dark history of witchcraft, cannibalism, and violence against women. Into this bleak place, the light…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… Blessed Gennaro Maria Sarnelli

By CAROLE BRESLIN In the history of the Church saints have commonly lived at the same time and worked together for the Kingdom of God. Pope St. John Paul II and St. Teresa of Calcutta, St. John of Avila (of the Cross) and St. Teresa of Avila, and St. Alphonsus Maria Liguori and Blessed Gennaro Maria Sarnelli. Blessed Gennaro was…Continue Reading