Wednesday 5th August 2020

Home » Frontpage » Currently Reading:

Has Capital Punishment Always Been “A Mortal Sin”?

May 31, 2017 Frontpage No Comments

Image result for electric chair

By FR. BRIAN W. HARRISON, OS

In a homily preached at Domus Sanctae Marthae on May 11, Pope Francis made some observations about the ethical status of capital punishment. In this article I wish to explain how his teaching here is seriously at variance with the doctrine of all his Predecessors and two successive universal catechisms, and to consider how faithful Catholics should respond to it.
First, what exactly did the Pope say? The original Italian-language report of the homily can be found here:
http://w2.vatican.va/content/francesco/it/cotidie/2017/documents/papa-francesco-cotidie_20170511_in-cammino.html
As is usual in the official reportage of these “meditations” given at weekday papal Masses (which are also published in the Vatican’s newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano), the Pope’s own words are not reproduced in full. Instead, his main points are either cited or paraphrased. The next three paragraphs are an unabridged translation of the relevant part of the Vatican’s report of Pope Francis’ May 11 homily, with italicization added in order to bring out the content that needs emphasis here.
The paragraph divisions are those found in the original report, and the words in single quotation marks are those it cites as being those of the Holy Father himself:
“[The historical development of doctrine], the Pope explained, enables us ‘to understand more deeply the person of Jesus, to deepen our faith’, thanks to ‘the Holy Spirit whom Jesus has left with us’. He added that this also enables us ‘to understand morality, the commandments’. In fact, he pointed out, ‘something that formerly seemed normal, and not sinful’ is today considered a ‘mortal sin’: in reality ‘it was a sin, but that historical period did not allow it to be perceived as such’.
“For a better understanding of this concept, Francis gave some examples, beginning with slavery: ‘When we went to school’, he recalled, ‘they told us what people used to do to slaves: they were transported from one place and sold in another; in Latin America they were bought, they were sold’. That is considered ‘mortally sinful’ today, but it wasn’t back then. ‘Indeed, some used to say that it was legitimate to do such things, because those people didn’t have souls!’ Obviously, ‘it was necessary to go forward in order to understand the faith better, to understand morality better’. It’s not that today there are no more slaves: ‘There are more than ever, but at least we know that it is mortally sinful’.
“The same process has taken place in regard to ‘the death penalty, which in former times was something normal. And today we say that it is inadmissible’. Or again, think of the ‘wars of religion’: today, said the Pontiff, ‘we know that this is not only mortally sinful, it is truly sacrilegious, a form of idolatry’.”
A clear message emerges from the above three paragraphs: Pope Francis is teaching that some practices formerly accepted by Christians as morally legitimate — and he gives as examples slavery, capital punishment and “wars of religion” — are now, thanks to the Holy Spirit’s ongoing influence in the Church, recognized as having been in reality (i.e., objectively) sinful, and indeed, mortally sinful.
I would respectfully suggest that bracketing slavery and ‘wars of religion’ together with the death penalty in this context with is theologically and historically superficial and misleading. However, in this brief article I will not attempt to explain why I see no relevant parallel between what Scripture, Tradition and the Magisterium have said about the first two issues and what they have said about capital punishment. I will confine my observations to this last issue.
The fact that the present Holy Father has expressed strong disapproval of the death penalty is not in itself surprising. For in his address to the U.S. Congress in September 2015 he called for its abolition, and several months later, in article 86 of his Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, he asserted, “The Church . . . firmly rejects the death penalty”. However, these brief assertions are not altogether clear in their implications. They are compatible with the view that the Church does not exclude capital punishment in principle, but that under modern circumstances — that is, taking into account recent social and cultural developments, advances in criminology, law enforcement, rehabilitation, the need for a clearer witness against today’s ‘culture of death’, etc. — she holds that this extreme penalty is now rarely if ever justifiable, and so should be legally abolished.
Now, that kind of teaching would be a contemporary prudential judgment that remains in harmony with traditional Catholic doctrine. It would be essentially identical to Pope St. John Paul II’s judgment in his 1995 Encyclical Evangelium Vitae, the relevant article of which (no. 56) is cited in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (n. 2267).
And as then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger pointed out in a 2004 letter to the U.S. Bishops, respectful disagreement with the current Pope’s prudential judgments regarding such questions as when the death penalty should be applied, and the justice of a given war, can be legitimate for faithful Catholics. Such disagreement, said the then-Prefect of the Vatican’s doctrinal Congregation, does not exclude one from the sacraments and should not be placed on a par with dissent from truly doctrinal teachings such as the intrinsic immorality of direct abortion and euthanasia.
However, in bluntly calling the death penalty “inadmissible” without linking this judgment to modern circumstances, and above all by teaching that capital punishment has always been objectively mortally sinful, but that former historical conditions prevented Christians from recognizing this (“in realtà ‘era peccato, ma il momento storico non permetteva che lo percepisse come tale’”), Pope Francis is audaciously taking a step — or rather, a giant leap! — further than any of his Predecessors.
What he says amounts to a brand-new doctrinal judgment to the effect that capital punishment is intrinsically and gravely evil. That is, the Holy Father is contradicting Cardinal Ratzinger’s letter by putting the judicial killing of those guilty of grave crimes and the killing of the innocent on the same ethical level — the level of mortal sin. However, as we shall see, it is not merely the Prefect of a Vatican dicastery who is being contradicted by the present Pontiff.
Francis claims that his novel doctrine against capital punishment has now emerged through the Holy Spirit’s assistance to the Church as she gradually “deepens” her understanding of morality and the Commandments. But the orthodox understanding of doctrinal development under the Holy Spirit’s guidance, as expounded by great theologians such as Blessed John Henry Newman, is that any new theological thesis that contradicts previous Church teaching, rather than explaining it more fully, is a corruption, not a true development, of Catholic doctrine. And unfortunately, a contradiction of the previous firm and constant teaching of the universal and ordinary Magisterium is what we see here.
Consider, for instance, the Church’s response to the mediaeval Waldensians, a pacifist sect with heretical ideas about the sacraments and certain other Catholic doctrines. They taught precisely what Pope Francis is now teaching, namely, that the death penalty is “mortal sin”; and Pope Innocent III condemned this error in 1210 by adding the following declaration to a 1208 profession of faith to be made by the said sectarians as a condition for being received back into the Church:
“Regarding the secular power, we assert that it may without mortal sin exercise the death penalty, provided this is imposed through justice, not hatred, and proceeds after due consultation, not incautiously.” (De potestate saeculari asserimus, quod sine peccato mortali potest iudicium sanguinis exercere, dummodo ad inferendam vindictam non odio, sed iudicio, non incaute, sed consulte procedat. DS 795 = Dz 425, emphasis added.)
Thus, we are now faced with the troubling spectacle of a Successor of Peter whose doctrine, in the eyes of many of his own Predecessors, would not have even allowed him admission to the Catholic Church, let alone the Throne of Peter! Indeed, this novel teaching implies that the Church founded by Christ, and endowed with the promise of His Spirit to guide her into all truth and to bind and loose in Heaven what she binds and looses on earth, actually received less enlightenment from the Holy Spirit in the 13th century than a small heretical sect.
For if Pope Francis is right, she not only censured its members for telling the truth about a grave matter regarding criminal justice, but required them to formally profess a false doctrine — to approve a mortally sinful practice — as a condition for membership in the Christ’s Church! Would not such a shocking scenario assail the credibility of the Catholic Church’s fundamental claim to be the unique authentic herald and interpreter on earth of the Gospel and Law of Christ? Isn’t the Holy Father, therefore, now undermining his own magisterial credibility — sawing off the branch on which he sits?
After several more centuries of unanimous and unwavering endorsement of capital punishment by Popes and bishops, their supposedly false doctrine was enshrined in the Roman Catechism (of the Council of Trent), which for four more centuries became the gold standard for the sound doctrinal formation of Catholics round the world until it was replaced by the post-Vatican II CCC. (This too, as we have seen, upholds the traditional doctrine on capital punishment.) In expounding the Fifth Commandment the Roman Catechism asserts that, in justly executing criminals, “[magistrates] are not only not guilty of murder, but eminently obey this law which prohibits murder,” for they are thereby “giving security to life by punishing and thus repressing audacity and outrage” (Part II, Ch. VI, Q. 4).
Pope Francis, in his recent homily, also implies (unwittingly, please God) that Sacred Scripture is in error — and in passages endorsing the death penalty that are certainly recorded “for the sake of our salvation” (cf. Genesis 9:5-6; Romans 13:3-4, and Vatican II, Dei Verbum, 11). Indeed, what could be more quintessentially relevant to our salvation than whether a certain kind of act is or is not mortally sinful? Thus, even those modern biblical critics who claim (mistakenly) that according to Vatican II all biblical affirmations can be grouped into two subsets, salvifically relevant and salvifically irrelevant, and that only the former subset is guaranteed to be free from error, would have to admit that Francis is implicitly contradicting Vatican II’s teaching on the truth of Scripture.
The error about capital punishment expressed by the Holy Father on May 11 seems to me even more serious than that expressed in the notorious homilies preached by Pope John XXII in the 1330s, affirming that after death the saints must wait until the Day of Judgment to enjoy the beatific vision. For these homilies were preached before the Magisterium of Peter’s See had clearly intervened to clarify and settle this question. The open opposition and criticism that Pope John aroused among orthodox theologians, leading him to retract his error shortly before he died, was based rather on the strong (though not unanimous) consensus of the great Fathers and Doctors, who had long interpreted Scripture as teaching that the souls of the saints in Heaven are already enjoying the direct vision of God. Moreover, a mistake about the post-mortem condition of saints at least does not unleash or encourage any unjust suffering here on earth.
But if the present Pope is right about capital punishment, the true Church of Christ, for almost two millennia, has been calamitously responsible for blessing and fostering with her constant and authoritative magisterial teaching the unjust shedding of the blood of hundreds of thousands of men and women.
We must surely believe that the Holy Spirit could never allow that to happen. On the contrary, Pope Francis, in branding capital punishment as such “mortally sinful” and “inadmissible,” is mistakenly reviving a doctrinal thesis already explicitly rejected by the ordinary and universal Magisterium of all his Predecessors and Catholic bishops, as well as by approved theologians and catechisms.
At least this deplorable error was made in an intervention of very low magisterial weight. Indeed, the Vatican website doesn’t even grant the Pope’s remarks at his semi-private weekday Masses the status of “Homilies”. They are accessed separately from the latter through a button further down the home page entitled “Daily Meditations”. This particular erroneous “meditation” must be resisted and corrected, just as the aforesaid 14th-century theologians resisted and corrected Pope John XXII.

Share Button

2019 The Wanderer Printing Co.

Twitter Feed

How can the University of Notre Dame claim to be a Catholic college and hire pro-abortion Pete Buttigieg as a faculty fellow?

Load More...

Planned Parenthood acknowledges Margaret Sanger’s ‘racist legacy’, continues abortions

CNA Staff, Jul 21, 2020 / 11:05 am MT (CNA).- The New York affiliate of the nation’s largest abortion provider said Tuesday it will remove the name of its founder, Margaret Sanger, from its Manhattan building because of her support…Continue Reading

Statue of Virgin Mary beheaded at Tennessee parish

CNA Staff, Jul 15, 2020 / 10:40 am MT (CNA).- A statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary was attacked this weekend at a parish in Chattanooga, Tennessee, the third reported incident against a statue of Mary occuring in the same…Continue Reading

21 doctors tell bishops Communion on tongue ‘safer’ than in hand

June 26, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) – Twenty-one Austrian doctors have authored a letter appealing their country’s Bishops’ Conference to lift the de facto ban on receiving Holy Communion on the tongue, which has been enforced since Communion in the hand was…Continue Reading

Catholic priest among defenders of St Louis statue

CNA Staff, Jun 27, 2020 / 09:36 pm MT (CNA).- Fr. Stephen Schumacher, a priest of the Archdiocese of St. Louis, was among the defenders of a prominent statue of the city’s namesake as protesters called for its removal Saturday.…Continue Reading

‘I cannot remain silent’: Madison Catholic bishop condemns destruction of religious statues

Denver Newsroom, Jun 24, 2020 / 04:08 pm MT (CNA).- As rioters across the United States target statues depicting historical figures, the Bishop of Madison, Wisconsin on Tuesday denounced that destruction, along with calls to destroy some depictions of Jesus…Continue Reading

John Roberts tries to suppress Reagan’s letter

After three and a half years of legal wrangling, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors in August of 1985 ordered the 16,433 mangled babies’ bodies found in Woodland Hills in 1982 to be turned over to the Guerra-Gutirrez-Alexander Mortuary…Continue Reading

Pope Francis declares Catholic sister killed in Satanic ritual a martyr

Vatican City, Jun 19, 2020 / 12:40 pm MT (CNA).- Pope Francis declared Friday that Sister Maria Laura Mainetti, an Italian religious sister killed by three teenage girls in a Satanic sacrifice, was a martyr for the Catholic faith. The…Continue Reading

Bishop Schneider: Catholics and Muslims share no common faith in God, no common adoration

June 8, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) – Bishop Athanasius Schneider has once more raised his voice concerning the controversial February 4, 2019 Abu Dhabi Statement on Human Fraternity where Pope Francis and a Grand Imam jointly declared, among other problematic statements, that God wills…Continue Reading

German cardinal criticizes ‘synodal path,’ exhorts German Church to ‘remain Catholic’

COLOGNE, Germany, June 5, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) — Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, the head of the Archdiocese of Cologne in Germany, has called on the Church in Germany to strengthen its identity as part of the one, holy, Catholic, and apostolic…Continue Reading

US bishop reverses plan to ban Communion on tongue as churches reopen

LAFAYETTE, Louisiana, May 15, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) – Bishop Douglas Deshotel has revised his decision to allow only reception of the Eucharist in the hand amid the coronavirus pandemic. He credited guidelines issued by the Thomistic Institute for correcting his previous…Continue Reading

Sainthood causes open for St John Paul II’s parents

A ceremony launching the causes of the Wojtyłas took place at the Basilica of the Presentation of the Blessed Virgin Mary in Wadowice, John Paul II’s birthplace. At the ceremony, the Kraków Archdiocese officially formed the tribunals that will seek…Continue Reading

President Trump on National Day of Prayer: “Never Forget That All Things are Possible With God”

On this National Day of Prayer, Americans reaffirm that prayer guides and strengthens our Nation, and we express, with humility and gratitude, our “firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence.”  As one Nation under God, we share a legacy…Continue Reading

Untitled 5 Untitled 2

Attention Readers:

  Welcome to our website. Readers who are familiar with The Wanderer know we have been providing Catholic news and orthodox commentary for 150 years in our weekly print edition.


  Our daily version offers only some of what we publish weekly in print. To take advantage of everything The Wanderer publishes, we encourage you to su
bscribe to our flagship weekly print edition, which is mailed every Friday or, if you want to view it in its entirety online, you can subscribe to the E-edition, which is a replica of the print edition.
 
  Our daily edition includes: a selection of material from recent issues of our print edition, news stories updated daily from renowned news sources, access to archives from The Wanderer from the past 10 years, available at a minimum charge (this will be expanded as time goes on). Also: regularly updated features where we go back in time and highlight various columns and news items covered in The Wanderer over the past 150 years. And: a comments section in which your remarks are encouraged, both good and bad, including suggestions.
 
  We encourage you to become a daily visitor to our site. If you appreciate our site, tell your friends. As Catholics we must band together to rediscover our faith and share it with the world if we are to effectively counter a society whose moral culture seems to have no boundaries and a government whose rapidly extending reach threatens to extinguish the rights of people of faith to practice their religion (witness the HHS mandate). Now more than ever, vehicles like The Wanderer are needed for clarification and guidance on the issues of the day.

Catholic, conservative, orthodox, and loyal to the Magisterium have been this journal’s hallmarks for five generations. God willing, our message will continue well into this century and beyond.

Joseph Matt
President, The Wanderer Printing Co.

Untitled 1

Interview With Cardinal Burke . . . Discriminating Mercy: Defending Christ And His Church With True Love

  By DON FIER (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke, Patron of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta and Founder of the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, Wis., graciously took time out of his busy schedule to grant The Wanderer a wide-ranging interview during a recent visit to the Shrine. Included among the topics…Continue Reading

Developing Lives Of Peace After The Heart Of Mary

By RAYMOND LEO CARDINAL BURKE (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke delivered the address below at the 32nd Annual Church Teaches Forum, “The Message of Fatima: Peace for the World,” Galt House, Louisville, Ky., July 22, 2017. The address is reprinted here with the kind permission of Cardinal Burke. All rights reserved. This is part one of the…Continue Reading

Catechism

Today . . .

After AOC decries statue, Hawaiian Catholic says St Damien of Molokai ‘gave his life’ serving lepers

Washington, D.C. Newsroom, Jul 31, 2020 / 01:28 pm MT (CNA).-   A Hawaiian Catholic catechist said that St. Damien of Molokai is a “hero” to the Hawaiian people, after a prominent congresswoman claimed the statue honoring him in the U.S. Capitol is part of colonialism and “patriarchy and white supremacist culture.”  St. Damien “gave his life” serving the isolated leper colony at Kalaupapa peninsula on the Hawaiian island of Molokai, said Dallas Carter, a…Continue Reading

Catholic bishops fear Scotland’s hate crime law could criminalize Bible and Catechism

CNA Staff, Jul 29, 2020 / 06:00 am MT (CNA).- Catholic bishops have said that proposed hate crime legislation in Scotland could criminalize the Bible and the Catechism of the Catholic Church.  In a statement issued July 29, the bishops argued that the Scottish Government’s new Hate Crime and Public Order Bill could lead to censorship of Catholic teaching. “We are also concerned that section 5 of the Bill creates an offense of possessing inflammatory material which, if taken…Continue Reading

Catholic schools plan waivers, remote learning, as officials weigh safe reopenings

Denver Newsroom, Jul 31, 2020 / 03:00 am MT (CNA).- As the beginning of the fall school term approaches, Catholic schools in dioceses across the U.S. are asking the parents of students returning in person to sign waivers of liability amid the risk of coronavirus infection. At the same time, many dioceses are also offering remote learning options for parents who do not wish to send their children back to school in person. One such…Continue Reading

Fire torches Catholic parish offices, chapel in North Carolina

Denver Newsroom, Jul 28, 2020 / 02:30 pm MT (CNA).- A fire tore through the parish offices of a historic Catholic church in Monroe, North Carolina early Monday morning, and though the damage is extensive, the church’s pastor is thankful that the blaze did not touch the main sanctuary or the Blessed Sacrament. Father Benjamin Roberts told CNA he arrived at Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church on Monday morn

Priests for Life Fr. Frank Pavone resigns from Trump campaign roles

Priests for Life national director Fr. Frank Pavone has resigned from advisory positions in the reelection campaign of President Donald Trump. The priest withdrew at the direction of Church authorities, he told CNA Friday. “I’ve been requested by the competent ecclesiastical authority not to have an official title/position on the advisory boards. So, as a priest in good standing, I’ve followed that request,” Pavone told CNA July 24, in response to questions about his role…Continue Reading

The Bishop Strickland Hour – Week of July 28

Turkey’s Erdogan… Sparks Controversy In Hagia Sophia Conversion

By JOHN J. METZLER (Editor’s Note: John J. Metzler is a United Nations correspondent covering diplomatic and defense issues. He is the author of Divided Dynamism: The Diplomacy of Separated Nations; Germany, Korea, China.) + + Its very name Hagia Sophia evokes the ancient mysteries of Byzantium. Its setting along the Golden Horn on the…Continue Reading

Our Problem Is Not Too Many Babies, But Too Few Babies

By STEVEN MOSHER (Editor’s Note: Steven W. Mosher [@StevenWMosher] is the president of the Population Research Institute and the author of Bully of Asia: Why China’s Dream Is the New Threat to World Order. LifeSiteNews first published this commentary on July 27.) + + (LifeSiteNews) — Amidst all the gloom and doom about overpopulation, occasionally…Continue Reading

Is Dialogue Possible Any Longer?

By DONALD DeMARCO The meaning of the word “dialogue” is to speak across (dia) the “logos.” The “logos” refers to the source of reason that makes it possible for people to see the same thing. Reason unites because it is the common reality that binds people together. For Catholics, the “logos” is the “Word,” and…Continue Reading

American “Stormtroopers” — A Bright Shining Lie

By PATRICK J. BUCHANAN With the Mark O. Hatfield United States Courthouse under nightly siege from violent radicals, and Portland’s police hard-pressed to protect it, President Trump sent in federal agents to secure the building.The reaction from Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi:“The use of Stormtroopers under the guise of law and order is a…Continue Reading

Who’s Standing Up For Him? Now They’re Targeting God

By BARBARA SIMPSON (Editor’s Note: This article first appeared on WorldNetDaily, www.wnd.com, July 17. All rights reserved. Barbara Simpson has a 20-year radio, TV, and newspaper career in the Bay Area and Los Angeles.) + + Just in case people haven’t noticed, probably because mainstream media ignore or downplay them, there’s been a rash of…Continue Reading

Advertisement

Our Catholic Faith (Section B of print edition)

Elijah Hears The Voice Of The Lord

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Nineteenth Sunday In Ordinary Time (YR A) Readings: 1 Kings 19:9a, 11-13aRomans 9:1-5Matt. 14:22-33 In the first reading today, we are given insight into the life of prayer. Elijah goes to Mount Horeb, which is also Mount Sinai, and there he experiences a number of powerful and even terrifying events: wind, earthquake, and fire. The Lord…Continue Reading

Bishop Strickland . . . On Sunday, The Lord’s Day, And Our Day

By MOST REV. JOSEPH STRICKLAND In an inspiring apostolic letter entitled The Lord’s Day (Dies Domini), issued on Pentecost Sunday 1998, Pope St. John Paul II gave a masterful summary of the Christian understanding of Sunday, and underscored our obligation to honor the Lord’s Day. The letter began with these words:“The Lord’s Day — as Sunday was called from apostolic…Continue Reading

Catholic Replies

Editor’s Note: Commenting in his parish bulletin about the “cancel culture” of recent days, Fr. George Rutler of the Church of St. Michael in New York City mentioned the efforts to censor such patriotic songs as America the Beautiful. He said that “there are also demands to eliminate our National Anthem because the author owned slaves. In fact, Francis Scott…Continue Reading

A Leaven In The World… They Fought Back And Won

By FR. KEVIN M. CUSICK The news hit the skids this past week about my parishioners Sid and Susanna Marcus who fought back against Big COVID19 and won.I don’t know for sure, being a layman when it comes to medical issues, but doctors who are a lot smarter than I am, such as Vernon Coleman, seem to think the stats…Continue Reading

Nothing Can Separate Us From The Lord

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Eighteenth Sunday In Ordinary Time (YR A) Readings: Isaiah 55:1-3Romans 8:35, 37-39Matt. 14:13-21 In the second reading today, St. Paul asks the question: “What will separate us from the love of Christ?” He goes on to give a number of possible conditions that could separate us from Christ: anguish, distress, persecution, famine, nakedness, peril, or the…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes . . . St. Charles Lwanga Of Uganda And Companions

By DEB PIROCH As the world becomes increasingly politically correct, we would do well to remember the sainthood of St. Charles Lwanga and his 24 or more companions who went to their deaths over 160 years ago, upholding chastity and resisting the deviant sexuality ordered by their king.Born in Buganda in south-central Uganda under the rule of good King Muteesa…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes . . . St. Valentine: Saint Of Love And Epilepsy

By DEB PIROCH One . . . or two? During the reign of Roman Emperor Claudius II, we hear of the martyrdom of St. Valentine. Changes were occurring in the Roman Empire; in the third century governments as opposed to mere local authorities began persecution of Christians and forbade conversion to the faith. It was circa AD 269 that St.…Continue Reading

Advertisement(2)