Sunday 15th September 2019

Home » Frontpage » Currently Reading:

Has Capital Punishment Always Been “A Mortal Sin”?

May 31, 2017 Frontpage No Comments

Image result for electric chair

By FR. BRIAN W. HARRISON, OS

In a homily preached at Domus Sanctae Marthae on May 11, Pope Francis made some observations about the ethical status of capital punishment. In this article I wish to explain how his teaching here is seriously at variance with the doctrine of all his Predecessors and two successive universal catechisms, and to consider how faithful Catholics should respond to it.
First, what exactly did the Pope say? The original Italian-language report of the homily can be found here:
http://w2.vatican.va/content/francesco/it/cotidie/2017/documents/papa-francesco-cotidie_20170511_in-cammino.html
As is usual in the official reportage of these “meditations” given at weekday papal Masses (which are also published in the Vatican’s newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano), the Pope’s own words are not reproduced in full. Instead, his main points are either cited or paraphrased. The next three paragraphs are an unabridged translation of the relevant part of the Vatican’s report of Pope Francis’ May 11 homily, with italicization added in order to bring out the content that needs emphasis here.
The paragraph divisions are those found in the original report, and the words in single quotation marks are those it cites as being those of the Holy Father himself:
“[The historical development of doctrine], the Pope explained, enables us ‘to understand more deeply the person of Jesus, to deepen our faith’, thanks to ‘the Holy Spirit whom Jesus has left with us’. He added that this also enables us ‘to understand morality, the commandments’. In fact, he pointed out, ‘something that formerly seemed normal, and not sinful’ is today considered a ‘mortal sin’: in reality ‘it was a sin, but that historical period did not allow it to be perceived as such’.
“For a better understanding of this concept, Francis gave some examples, beginning with slavery: ‘When we went to school’, he recalled, ‘they told us what people used to do to slaves: they were transported from one place and sold in another; in Latin America they were bought, they were sold’. That is considered ‘mortally sinful’ today, but it wasn’t back then. ‘Indeed, some used to say that it was legitimate to do such things, because those people didn’t have souls!’ Obviously, ‘it was necessary to go forward in order to understand the faith better, to understand morality better’. It’s not that today there are no more slaves: ‘There are more than ever, but at least we know that it is mortally sinful’.
“The same process has taken place in regard to ‘the death penalty, which in former times was something normal. And today we say that it is inadmissible’. Or again, think of the ‘wars of religion’: today, said the Pontiff, ‘we know that this is not only mortally sinful, it is truly sacrilegious, a form of idolatry’.”
A clear message emerges from the above three paragraphs: Pope Francis is teaching that some practices formerly accepted by Christians as morally legitimate — and he gives as examples slavery, capital punishment and “wars of religion” — are now, thanks to the Holy Spirit’s ongoing influence in the Church, recognized as having been in reality (i.e., objectively) sinful, and indeed, mortally sinful.
I would respectfully suggest that bracketing slavery and ‘wars of religion’ together with the death penalty in this context with is theologically and historically superficial and misleading. However, in this brief article I will not attempt to explain why I see no relevant parallel between what Scripture, Tradition and the Magisterium have said about the first two issues and what they have said about capital punishment. I will confine my observations to this last issue.
The fact that the present Holy Father has expressed strong disapproval of the death penalty is not in itself surprising. For in his address to the U.S. Congress in September 2015 he called for its abolition, and several months later, in article 86 of his Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, he asserted, “The Church . . . firmly rejects the death penalty”. However, these brief assertions are not altogether clear in their implications. They are compatible with the view that the Church does not exclude capital punishment in principle, but that under modern circumstances — that is, taking into account recent social and cultural developments, advances in criminology, law enforcement, rehabilitation, the need for a clearer witness against today’s ‘culture of death’, etc. — she holds that this extreme penalty is now rarely if ever justifiable, and so should be legally abolished.
Now, that kind of teaching would be a contemporary prudential judgment that remains in harmony with traditional Catholic doctrine. It would be essentially identical to Pope St. John Paul II’s judgment in his 1995 Encyclical Evangelium Vitae, the relevant article of which (no. 56) is cited in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (n. 2267).
And as then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger pointed out in a 2004 letter to the U.S. Bishops, respectful disagreement with the current Pope’s prudential judgments regarding such questions as when the death penalty should be applied, and the justice of a given war, can be legitimate for faithful Catholics. Such disagreement, said the then-Prefect of the Vatican’s doctrinal Congregation, does not exclude one from the sacraments and should not be placed on a par with dissent from truly doctrinal teachings such as the intrinsic immorality of direct abortion and euthanasia.
However, in bluntly calling the death penalty “inadmissible” without linking this judgment to modern circumstances, and above all by teaching that capital punishment has always been objectively mortally sinful, but that former historical conditions prevented Christians from recognizing this (“in realtà ‘era peccato, ma il momento storico non permetteva che lo percepisse come tale’”), Pope Francis is audaciously taking a step — or rather, a giant leap! — further than any of his Predecessors.
What he says amounts to a brand-new doctrinal judgment to the effect that capital punishment is intrinsically and gravely evil. That is, the Holy Father is contradicting Cardinal Ratzinger’s letter by putting the judicial killing of those guilty of grave crimes and the killing of the innocent on the same ethical level — the level of mortal sin. However, as we shall see, it is not merely the Prefect of a Vatican dicastery who is being contradicted by the present Pontiff.
Francis claims that his novel doctrine against capital punishment has now emerged through the Holy Spirit’s assistance to the Church as she gradually “deepens” her understanding of morality and the Commandments. But the orthodox understanding of doctrinal development under the Holy Spirit’s guidance, as expounded by great theologians such as Blessed John Henry Newman, is that any new theological thesis that contradicts previous Church teaching, rather than explaining it more fully, is a corruption, not a true development, of Catholic doctrine. And unfortunately, a contradiction of the previous firm and constant teaching of the universal and ordinary Magisterium is what we see here.
Consider, for instance, the Church’s response to the mediaeval Waldensians, a pacifist sect with heretical ideas about the sacraments and certain other Catholic doctrines. They taught precisely what Pope Francis is now teaching, namely, that the death penalty is “mortal sin”; and Pope Innocent III condemned this error in 1210 by adding the following declaration to a 1208 profession of faith to be made by the said sectarians as a condition for being received back into the Church:
“Regarding the secular power, we assert that it may without mortal sin exercise the death penalty, provided this is imposed through justice, not hatred, and proceeds after due consultation, not incautiously.” (De potestate saeculari asserimus, quod sine peccato mortali potest iudicium sanguinis exercere, dummodo ad inferendam vindictam non odio, sed iudicio, non incaute, sed consulte procedat. DS 795 = Dz 425, emphasis added.)
Thus, we are now faced with the troubling spectacle of a Successor of Peter whose doctrine, in the eyes of many of his own Predecessors, would not have even allowed him admission to the Catholic Church, let alone the Throne of Peter! Indeed, this novel teaching implies that the Church founded by Christ, and endowed with the promise of His Spirit to guide her into all truth and to bind and loose in Heaven what she binds and looses on earth, actually received less enlightenment from the Holy Spirit in the 13th century than a small heretical sect.
For if Pope Francis is right, she not only censured its members for telling the truth about a grave matter regarding criminal justice, but required them to formally profess a false doctrine — to approve a mortally sinful practice — as a condition for membership in the Christ’s Church! Would not such a shocking scenario assail the credibility of the Catholic Church’s fundamental claim to be the unique authentic herald and interpreter on earth of the Gospel and Law of Christ? Isn’t the Holy Father, therefore, now undermining his own magisterial credibility — sawing off the branch on which he sits?
After several more centuries of unanimous and unwavering endorsement of capital punishment by Popes and bishops, their supposedly false doctrine was enshrined in the Roman Catechism (of the Council of Trent), which for four more centuries became the gold standard for the sound doctrinal formation of Catholics round the world until it was replaced by the post-Vatican II CCC. (This too, as we have seen, upholds the traditional doctrine on capital punishment.) In expounding the Fifth Commandment the Roman Catechism asserts that, in justly executing criminals, “[magistrates] are not only not guilty of murder, but eminently obey this law which prohibits murder,” for they are thereby “giving security to life by punishing and thus repressing audacity and outrage” (Part II, Ch. VI, Q. 4).
Pope Francis, in his recent homily, also implies (unwittingly, please God) that Sacred Scripture is in error — and in passages endorsing the death penalty that are certainly recorded “for the sake of our salvation” (cf. Genesis 9:5-6; Romans 13:3-4, and Vatican II, Dei Verbum, 11). Indeed, what could be more quintessentially relevant to our salvation than whether a certain kind of act is or is not mortally sinful? Thus, even those modern biblical critics who claim (mistakenly) that according to Vatican II all biblical affirmations can be grouped into two subsets, salvifically relevant and salvifically irrelevant, and that only the former subset is guaranteed to be free from error, would have to admit that Francis is implicitly contradicting Vatican II’s teaching on the truth of Scripture.
The error about capital punishment expressed by the Holy Father on May 11 seems to me even more serious than that expressed in the notorious homilies preached by Pope John XXII in the 1330s, affirming that after death the saints must wait until the Day of Judgment to enjoy the beatific vision. For these homilies were preached before the Magisterium of Peter’s See had clearly intervened to clarify and settle this question. The open opposition and criticism that Pope John aroused among orthodox theologians, leading him to retract his error shortly before he died, was based rather on the strong (though not unanimous) consensus of the great Fathers and Doctors, who had long interpreted Scripture as teaching that the souls of the saints in Heaven are already enjoying the direct vision of God. Moreover, a mistake about the post-mortem condition of saints at least does not unleash or encourage any unjust suffering here on earth.
But if the present Pope is right about capital punishment, the true Church of Christ, for almost two millennia, has been calamitously responsible for blessing and fostering with her constant and authoritative magisterial teaching the unjust shedding of the blood of hundreds of thousands of men and women.
We must surely believe that the Holy Spirit could never allow that to happen. On the contrary, Pope Francis, in branding capital punishment as such “mortally sinful” and “inadmissible,” is mistakenly reviving a doctrinal thesis already explicitly rejected by the ordinary and universal Magisterium of all his Predecessors and Catholic bishops, as well as by approved theologians and catechisms.
At least this deplorable error was made in an intervention of very low magisterial weight. Indeed, the Vatican website doesn’t even grant the Pope’s remarks at his semi-private weekday Masses the status of “Homilies”. They are accessed separately from the latter through a button further down the home page entitled “Daily Meditations”. This particular erroneous “meditation” must be resisted and corrected, just as the aforesaid 14th-century theologians resisted and corrected Pope John XXII.

Share Button

2019 The Wanderer Printing Co.

Twitter Feed

I wonder how someone becomes an abortion doctor

Like what's going on in your mind when you choose that as your career

"Kill some babies? Hmmm.. yeah I guess I can see myself doing that for the next 30 or so years"

Controversial tweet. Might delete!

30 years ago, Catholics who warned about the homosexual abuse wracking the Church were reviled by bishops & ignored by major media. The late Paul Likoudis, intrepid and faithful researcher @TheWandererNews, was persona non grata @USCCB, but he's now been vindicated. deo gratias.

Stephen White on Twitter

“The ongoing circus in the Diocese of Buffalo should remind everyone: The price the Church pays for trying to save face is, in the end, always g...

twitter.com

Load More...

Missouri AG refers 12 former Catholic priests for potential prosecution after abuse probe

Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt announced Friday that his office had referred 12 former Roman Catholic priests for possible criminal prosecution following a 13-month probe of how diocesan leaders handled allegations of child abuse. The investigation reviewed personnel records for every priest serving…Continue Reading

Cardinal Burke, Bishop Schneider call for prayer crusade, cite dangers of Amazon Synod

Cardinal Raymond Burke and Bishop Athanasius Schneider have issued an eight-page declaration warning against six “serious theological errors and heresies” they say are contained in the Amazonian Synod working document, and calling for prayer and fasting to prevent them being approved. Cardinal Burke, patron…Continue Reading

Leader of Jesuit order: Satan doesn’t exist as ‘personal’ reality, only ‘symbolic’

August 22, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) – The devil is a not a personal reality but a symbol for evil, the head of the Jesuit order said this week. Satan, the devil whom the Catholic Church says was behind the fall of…Continue Reading

American Catholics Must Stand with Hong Kong

The autonomous territory of Hong Kong is in a fight for its life. For over two months, the citizens of Hong Kong have persisted in protesting an attempt by the Hong Kong chief executive to impose an amendment to the…Continue Reading

German archbishop in Auschwitz: Stand up against hubris of the politically powerful

Krakow, Poland, Aug 14, 2019 / 02:31 pm (CNA).- On the eve of the 80th anniversary of the German invasion of Poland, a German archbishop has called for a stand against hubris and arrogance of those in political power. Speaking…Continue Reading

Vatican ‘struggling to put out fire’ of public scandal over JPII Institute purge

ROME, August 15, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) — The “firefighters for the new direction” being taken at the John Paul II Institute in Rome are “struggling” to put out a blaze of public scandal, as controversy sparked by a recent purge of professors threatens to reach the door of the Pope’s…Continue Reading

Survey on Catholic belief in the Eucharist prompts calls for better catechesis

Washington D.C., Aug 10, 2019 / 03:32 pm (CNA).- After a recent survey found that two-thirds of Catholics do not believe Church teaching about the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, Catholic commenters are stressing the importance of better…Continue Reading

Apple News bans LifeSite without warning: says it ‘shows intolerance’

July 31, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) – A little over one week ago, Apple approved LifeSiteNews’ application to publish our news on their Apple News platform. Today, without warning, Apple News abruptly reversed course, telling LifeSite that they had deleted our channel and all…Continue Reading

Kamala Harris’ “Medicare for All” Plan Will Force Americans to Fund Abortions

Democrat presidential candidate Kamala Harris released her own Medicare-for-all proposal today. Just like the proposal handed down by pro-abortion presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, Harris’s plan would force Americans to fund abortions. Harris confirms her plan will cover abortions in an…Continue Reading

Pew report: Only half of America’s Catholics know what the Church teaches about Communion

WASHINGTON, D.C., July 26, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) ― Do only half of America’s Catholics know what their Church teaches about Holy Communion? In a recent report called “What Americans Know About Religion,” the Pew Research Center suggested that Catholics are divided…Continue Reading

Pro-Life Businessman Michael Lindell, Creator of MyPillow, May Run Against Pro-Abortion Ilhan Omar

Michael Lindell is a pro-life businessman and the creator of MyPillow, a successful invention and company in its own right. Lindell was responsible for helping to fund production of the popular movie “Unplanned,” but now he’s turning his attention to…Continue Reading

Tucker Carlson: big business is now at war against your family

July 15, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) – The first thing to note about Tucker Carlson is that when he’s on stage and riffing on his irritations, he is hilarious. He began his keynote speech at the National Conservatism conference in Washington, D.C. on Monday…Continue Reading

Untitled 5 Untitled 2

Attention Readers:

  Welcome to our website. Readers who are familiar with The Wanderer know we have been providing Catholic news and orthodox commentary for 150 years in our weekly print edition.


  Our daily version offers only some of what we publish weekly in print. To take advantage of everything The Wanderer publishes, we encourage you to su
bscribe to our flagship weekly print edition, which is mailed every Friday or, if you want to view it in its entirety online, you can subscribe to the E-edition, which is a replica of the print edition.
 
  Our daily edition includes: a selection of material from recent issues of our print edition, news stories updated daily from renowned news sources, access to archives from The Wanderer from the past 10 years, available at a minimum charge (this will be expanded as time goes on). Also: regularly updated features where we go back in time and highlight various columns and news items covered in The Wanderer over the past 150 years. And: a comments section in which your remarks are encouraged, both good and bad, including suggestions.
 
  We encourage you to become a daily visitor to our site. If you appreciate our site, tell your friends. As Catholics we must band together to rediscover our faith and share it with the world if we are to effectively counter a society whose moral culture seems to have no boundaries and a government whose rapidly extending reach threatens to extinguish the rights of people of faith to practice their religion (witness the HHS mandate). Now more than ever, vehicles like The Wanderer are needed for clarification and guidance on the issues of the day.

Catholic, conservative, orthodox, and loyal to the Magisterium have been this journal’s hallmarks for five generations. God willing, our message will continue well into this century and beyond.

Joseph Matt
President, The Wanderer Printing Co.

Untitled 1

Interview With Cardinal Burke . . . Discriminating Mercy: Defending Christ And His Church With True Love

Cburke3

  By DON FIER (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke, Patron of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta and Founder of the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, Wis., graciously took time out of his busy schedule to grant The Wanderer a wide-ranging interview during a recent visit to the Shrine. Included among the topics…Continue Reading

Developing Lives Of Peace After The Heart Of Mary

By RAYMOND LEO CARDINAL BURKE (Editor’s Note: His Eminence Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke delivered the address below at the 32nd Annual Church Teaches Forum, “The Message of Fatima: Peace for the World,” Galt House, Louisville, Ky., July 22, 2017. The address is reprinted here with the kind permission of Cardinal Burke. All rights reserved. This is part one of the…Continue Reading

Catechism

Today . . .

Rochester diocese, facing flood of sex-abuse claims, files for bankruptcy protection

ROCHESTER, N.Y. – The Roman Catholic Diocese of Rochester, facing potentially huge judgments for past sexual abuse by its priests and other ministers, filed for bankruptcy protection Thursday. “This was a very difficult and painful decision,” Rochester Bishop Salvatore Matano said at an afternoon news conference that detailed the action. The diocese filed its petition for Chapter 11 reorganization in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Rochester at about 9:30 a.m. The petition estimates the diocese’s…Continue Reading

A New Church?

St. Peter Claver was born at Verdu, Catalonia, Spain, in 1580, of impoverished parents descended from ancient families. He studied at the Jesuit college of Barcelona, entered the Jesuit novitiate at Tarragona in 1602, and took his final vows on August 8th, 1604. While studying, the young religious was influenced by St. Alphonsus Rodriguez to go to the Indies and save “millions of perishing souls.” In 1610, he landed at Cartagena (modern Colombia), the principle slave market of the New World, where a thousand slaves were landed every month. After his ordination in 1616,…Continue Reading

Pope Francis’ in-flight press conference

popef105

(Vatican News) Press conference on the flight back from his Apostolic Journey in Southern Africa: Pope Francis recalls the joy of the children he met and affirms that the State has the duty to take care of families. He says that xenophobia is “a disease” and asks that people’s identities be preserved from ideological colonization. He speaks of the criticisms he receives and replies to a question on schismatic temptations with: “I pray that schisms…Continue Reading

Half of Catholics attending Mass 28 years ago no longer do, figures show

You may have noticed the space in church pews widening between you and your fellow Catholics attending Sunday Mass in recent years. It is not your imagination. Mass attendance in parishes of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has been dropping for years, and several factors have steepened the long-term pattern of decline to the point where today, half as many Catholics in the archdiocese attend Mass regularly as did a generation ago. The findings of the…Continue Reading

Catholics to gather near Vatican next month to pray for Church in her hour of crisis

ROME, September 6, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — Catholics from around the world are being invited to assemble, on Oct. 5, near St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome, to pray for the Church as she lives through what many see as the hour of her “Passion.” The announcement came in a letter published on Sept. 6 on Stilum Curae, a blog hosted by respected Italian journalist Marco Tosatti. According to the letter (see full text below), an interna

Advertisement3

When The Obvious Is No Longer Obvious

By DONALD DeMARCO The late Fr. James Schall, SJ, was a great admirer of Samuel Johnson and, by his own admission, read something from Boswell’s Life of Johnson almost every day. Dr. Johnson was one of the most formidable figures of literature and life of the eighteenth century. He made lasting contributions as a poet,…Continue Reading

After Bolton, Trump Goals Remain Unrealized

By PATRICK J. BUCHANAN The sudden and bitter departure of John Bolton from the White House was baked in the cake from the day he arrived there. For Bolton’s worldview, formed and fixed in a Cold War that ended in 1991, was irreconcilable with the policies Donald Trump promised in his 2016 campaign. Indeed, Trump…Continue Reading

K Of C State Council . . . Helps Sponsor Cardinal Burke’s Upcoming Detroit Address

The State Council of Knights of Columbus made a generous donation to help Call to Holiness bring Raymond Cardinal Burke to speak at a dinner on October 26 outside Detroit. The cardinal’s celebration of Mass on the following day will contain all of the ceremony appropriate for a prince of the Church. Cardinal Burke was…Continue Reading

New Divorce Bill In The UK… The Case Against No Fault Divorce

By PIERS SHEPHERD On June 13, 2019, the British government published the Divorce, Dissolution, and Separation Bill. The purpose of this legislation is to remove the concept of “fault” from the divorce process, effectively allowing divorce on demand, subject to a six-month waiting period, and taking away any right of either party to contest the…Continue Reading

What Happened To The Concept Of “Person” In American Legal Theory?

By JUDE DOUGHERTY In a sense, there is no such thing as American legal theory. Like science, theory transcends national boundaries. The legal theory in the United States has deep roots in classical and medieval philosophy and more immediately in the British common law. To seek the roots of the current legal meaning of “person”…Continue Reading

Advertisement

Our Catholic Faith (Section B of print edition)

Catholic Replies

Q. There appears to be some speculation that Pope John Paul I was murdered during the Vatican Bank/Mafia scandal in the late Seventies, especially in the actions of Jean-Marie Cardinal Villot, who appeared shortly after the Pope’s death and essentially was responsible for cleaning and removing all possible evidence from the Holy Father’s bedroom. Your input, please. — R.B.K., via…Continue Reading

Founding Professor . . . Laments “Destruction” Of John Paul II Institute

(LifeSiteNews Editor’s Note: The following is an English translation of the “Public Statement Concerning the Turmoil Surrounding the Pope John Paul II Institute for the Family in Rome,” released on August 28. (The “Statement” was addressed to: Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia, Great Chancellor of the Institute; Monsignor Pierangelo Sequeri, President of the Institute; Cardinal Giuseppe Versaldi, prefect of the Congregation for…Continue Reading

We Need A Conversion Of Heart

By FR. ROBERT ALTIER Twenty-Fourth Sunday In Ordinary Time (YR C) Readings: Exodus 32:7-11, 13-14 1 Tim. 1:12-17 Luke 15:1-32 In the Gospel reading we are told that tax collectors and sinners were drawing near to listen to Jesus. This did not sit well with the Pharisees who complained, “This man welcomes sinners and eats with them.” Many things could…Continue Reading

A Leaven In The World… The Storm That Never Passes

By FR. KEVIN M. CUSICK “This too shall pass.” These words are often spoken in sympathy to those suffering the darkness of internal anguish or the mind-numbing pain of serious physical illness. Also, more famously, to someone enduring the storm breaking over him following criminal wrongdoing in the aftermath of Watergate: the president humiliated in resignation, Richard Nixon. Always true…Continue Reading

Catholic Replies

Q. On the controversial matter of whether to admit to Catholic schools children of same-sex parents, Bill Donohue of the Catholic League has written a very good article. Perhaps you could share it with your readers. — A.M.D., via e-mail. A. We are happy to do so. Here is some of what Mr. Donohue said: “Parents are not required to…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… St. Simon De Rojas

By CAROLE BRESLIN The subject of this article lived in a time of great saints, great Spanish saints, so it is not surprising that he is little known. St. Ignatius of Loyola (1491-1556) who wrote the Spiritual Exercises, St. Teresa of Avila (1515-1582) who reformed the Carmelites and wrote The Interior Castle, and St. John of the Cross who wrote…Continue Reading

Catholic Heroes… Child Martyrs Of Tlaxcala

By CAROLE BRESLIN Viva Cristo Rey! This was the call of the Cristeros (1926-1929). Many Mexican saints were martyred during that massive and demonic persecution of the Catholic Church. One young man, José Sanchez del Rio, was only 14 years old when he died for his loyalty to the faith. He had refused to deny Christ, even under torture. Three…Continue Reading

Advertisement(2)