In 1950, the year he won a Nobel Prize for Literature, Lord Bertrand Russell wrote an essay entitled, “An Outline of Intellectual Rubbish.” It was part of a collection of articles under the caption, Unpopular Essays.
Russell was as confident as he was brazen. In the essay, he challenged the time-honored definition of man. “Man is a rational animal,” he stated sarcastically. “So at least we have been told. Throughout a long life I have searched diligently for evidence in favor of this statement. So far, I have not had the good fortune to come across it.”
His challenge is well expressed. Russell was a master of the English language. He was also a brilliant mathematician. His well-crafted words, however, offer sufficient proof that he himself, Lord Russell, is indeed a rational animal.
He appears to be unaware of his own contradiction. Perhaps his cynicism got in the way of any clear-sightedness. He viewed Homo sapiens as being a creature dominated and organized by stupidity, pride, envy, and irrational passions. Nonetheless, he would not apply any of these vices to himself. He presumed to be wise enough to know that his own indubitable rationality was not merely another example of irrational man.
Despite his brilliance as a writer and as a mathematician, Russell was a very poor philosopher. In fact, one can say that he was no philosopher at all. His treatment of St. Thomas Aquinas, for example, is as wrongheaded as his comprehension of the nature of the human being. Moreover, it is rather far-fetched to say that one cannot detect evidence of rationality, even after many years of investigation. A glimpse of Big Ben should be enough to prove man’s rationality beyond any reasonable doubt.
Every alert human being by the age of five recognizes that human beings do things that do not reflect rationality. Paradoxically, his irrational moments prove that he is rational.
Unlike all other species in the animal kingdom, man has the power of reason. With this unique power he is able to make choices. He can choose to be faithful to his nature and behave rationally or he can deviate from his nature and make irrational choices. In other words, freedom of choice is part and parcel of his being rational.
Russell fails to distinguish between essence and activity. A talented painter has the capacity to produce bad paintings. But his activity does not define his essence any more than man’s irrational actions define him as irrational. Man is a rational animal in his essence. And if we need to appease Russell, we may state that man is a rational animal who sometimes does irrational things. This simple point does not require decades of observation.
Animals other than humans lack the freedom to be anything but themselves. The bee makes honey, the spider builds his webs, and the beaver builds his dams. They cannot take turns in doing what the other does. They are highly specialized. Their activities always conform to their nature. The horse cannot sing like a nightingale, nor does he want to. But oftentimes, it is said that man behaves like a wolf, or a pig, or a monkey, or, in the case of Dracula, like a vampire.
Beasts do not live a moral life. A lion does not experience guilt for killing and consuming a zebra. A tiger does not aspire to be king of the jungle. Man is a moral creature precisely because he has the obligation to be faithful to his rational nature and behave rationally and reasonably with other of his species. He is obliged not to act like a beast. He has the duty to be just, loving, and good.
The Great Ideas, as catalogued by a real philosopher, Mortimer Adler, are the ideals by which man should live. Beasts do not have ideals. Nor can they read or write. They live by instinct which never directs them from who they are by nature.
Russell has asserted that “the secret to happiness is to face the fact that the world is horrible.” He has the same evaluation of the world as he has of the human being.
The horrible, unlike the beautiful, has no potentiality for making people happy. In fact, it scares people half to death. No one would journey to the most horrible place on earth because he believes that is where he will be happiest. He does everything he can to avoid the horrible precisely because he is rational.
Russell’s cynicism goes beyond disagreement to vilification. The poet Robert Frost selected the phrase, “I had a lover’s quarrel with the world,” for his epitaph. It is inscribed on his gravestone in Bennington, Vt.
A “lover’s quarrel” is a disagreement born out of a deep affection. One can disagree while keeping love intact. Love is stronger than disagreement. Disagreement should not lead to condemnation. The presence of love is a dam against cynicism.
Frost leaves the world with a line of wisdom. That we can behold the crimes and follies perpetrated by man does not compromise our ability to love. Hope is more realistic than despair.
We can take Lord Russell’s words with a grain of salt. He was pugnacious. He wanted to show the world that he was smarter than tradition. But in setting reason aside, what he revealed was his own ego. Man remains, despite everything, a rational animal.